Debate paused on MP's bill for second-home controls

BBC St Ives viewed from higher ground on a sunny day. The headland and bay are visible and it is low tide. The bright blue sea extends beyond the headland to the horizon. The buildings are clustered around the harbour. There are many small craft moored in the harbour. In the foreground of the photo are trees, a church tower and a bell tower. BBC
St Ives MP Andrew George wants to see homes protected for local communities

A bid by a Cornwall MP to make second-home owners apply for planning permission has failed to secure a second reading in Parliament.

St Ives MP Andrew George proposed the Homes and Planning Bill in a bid to make owners apply for planning permission if they want to use their property as a second home or short-term holiday let.

Housing Minister Matthew Pennycook argued against the Lib Dem's private member's bill on Friday, however, Pennycook told the Commons he was "considering all options" to help people who live in seaside and rural counties access housing.

MPs agreed to pause the debate and it was adjourned until 15 January, however it is unlikely to become law without government backing.

George told MPs: "Our housing and planning system operates as if the housing needs of local people were an inconvenient afterthought."

He said it rewarded "land-value speculation more than charitable providers of affordable homes, puts developer profit before affordability of homes, and turns a blind eye to local homes becoming absorbed into property investment portfolios as second homes and holiday lets".

He called for councils and community groups to have extra powers to buy land, to support the development of social housing.

He said there were 2,700 holiday lets, including Airbnb listings, available in his constituency alone, as well as "65 private rents significantly above the local housing allowance levels available for private rent".

Cornwall Council recorded 13,140 second homes across the county in October 2023.

'Ebbing away'

George said houses that become private second homes, but not short-term lets, should revert back to permanent homes when they are sold.

Pennycook argued against George's proposal because "planning-use classes run with the land or building and they are not based on ownership".

George said some communities faced "a risk of proliferation of properties which are desperately needed for permanent occupancy, which are ebbing away from the local community and going for non-permanent use".

Pennycook said different parts of the world used licensing or planning rules, or a combination of both, to try to manage housing.

He said: "We share the ambition of improving access to housing for local people, but changes to the use-class system must be judged by whether they would achieve that objective in practice.

"We are not persuaded that the approach proposed in the [Bill] would work."

Follow BBC Cornwall on X, Facebook and Instagram. Follow BBC Devon on X, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to spotlight@bbc.co.uk.