No room to hide in force, says police chief

BBC A man with white grey short hair wearing a white shirt with Chief Constable epauletsBBC
Chief Constable James Vaughan said he was working hard to identify and remove bad officers

A police chief has vowed to do everything in his power to remove "bad officers" following accusations his force failed to investigate serving and former police officers for domestic abuse and sexual violence.

Devon and Cornwall Police Chief Constable James Vaughan admitted the force had racists, misogynists and people who abused their power but he said he was working tirelessly to identify and remove them.

"There is zero tolerance here, there is no room to hide," he warned.

After the BBC reported nine women had been paid compensation over police abuse claims, a former female officer alleged she was also sexually assaulted by a colleague on a work trip in Europe.

If you have been affected by any of the issues in this story, help and support is available at BBC Action Line.

Kay (not her real name) said she had a poor response from colleagues when she told them of the sex assault and was given no support.

"All I remember is going out of my body as he continued to violate me," she said.

"I managed to get out of that room and get back to my room somehow. I remember waking up a number of hours later just feeling disorientated [and] confused.

"I couldn't even recall what had happened so I couldn't really tell anyone."

When she got her memory back, she said she told a senior female officer and other colleagues but was given no support.

"They carried on laughing and joking with him when in my presence, which really messed with my head, but reinforced my belief that I just had to get over it so I just had to push it down and pretend it hadn't happened."

A picture of a blurred out woman in front of a tree with bright orange leaves
Kay said the officer who allegedly sexually assaulted her was "untouchable"

When she did officially report the alleged offence against the officer, who is now retired, the force said investigations were made in England and with overseas law enforcement.

Following Crown Prosecution Service advice regarding jurisdiction statutory time limits, a formal criminal investigation could not be progressed, said the force.

Kay said: "He was just one of the lads and has remained untouchable and unfortunately still is."

Devon and Cornwall Police compensated Kay, while the deputy chief constable wrote to her to apologise for the harm she suffered, for shortcomings in how the initial report was handled, for frustration around the delays to the investigation and the overall impact it had caused.

Force accepts failings

Chief Constable Vaughan said he was "utterly ashamed of the actions of a small minority of staff".

"The force has accepted and agreed the cases have not properly been managed and we haven't achieved justice where potentially we could have achieved justice," he said.

"I have accepted what they have said, I have apologised and I have compensated."

Vaughan said police perpetrated abuse was a major issue in policing generally and it was an issue in the force.

"In the 18 months I have been here, I have personally chaired 14 panels. In 12 of those panels, I personally dismissed officers for their behaviour that fell below the standards that we set," he said.

The force said it had introduced several measures to better support victims of police perpetrated abuse. They included:

  • Enhanced internal intelligence monitoring to identify concerning behaviour at the earliest opportunity
  • Cultural change programmes to address misogyny
  • Inappropriate conduct and bystander training alongside improved reporting mechanisms

The force said it had increased awareness of its internal domestic abuse peer support network and, along with other forces nationally, brought in more diligent pre-promotion vetting and intelligence checks.

Vaughn urged any victim of police perpetrated crime to report it and promised any any report would be properly and proportionately investigated.

"I ask you to place some trust in me and my senior officers in gripping this and dealing with this as we go forward," he said.

Follow BBC Cornwall on X, Facebook and Instagram. Follow BBC Devon on X, Facebook and Instagram. Send your story ideas to spotlight@bbc.co.uk.