The balancing act of police pursuits and the rules around them

Press Association A white car which has been hit by a car in LeedsPress Association
The latest crash happened in the early hours of Sunday morning just outside Leeds city centre

Since 29 October, three police pursuits in Leeds have ended in serious injury or death.

Three people have been killed and one person has been left seriously injured in crashes caused by cars being followed by officers.

Most recently, Cameron Bell, 22, and Jade Langton, 23, both from York, died in a collision just before 01:00 GMT on Sunday. A man appeared in court over the incident on Monday.

Baroness Alison Lowe, deputy mayor for crime and policing in West Yorkshire, said she has "no major concerns" about the force's pursuit rules - but what actually are they?

Guidance from The College of Policing says officers must determine whether a pursuit is justified and proportionate.

"If the decision is made to engage in a pursuit because it is in the public interest to protect life, prevent or detect crime, or to apprehend an offender, then it must be conducted with proportionality and due regard for the circumstances," the professional body states.

Pursuits should be authorised by control room staff, but officers do not always have the time to wait for the go-ahead and are allowed to "self-authorise" - though they must be able to justify their decision at a later stage.

Once a pursuit is launched, officers have to take a number of factors into account.

These include the level of risk posed by the pursued driver; the seriousness of any offence committed or suspected; the weight of intelligence as to whether a suspect is likely to be armed; whether young people are in the subject car; and the type of vehicle being pursued.

'Public safety'

The college adds: "It is important that the risks, topography and continuing surroundings are calculated to justify legitimacy of actions.

"Officers should not place undue pressure on themselves or risk public safety beyond their capabilities or those of the vehicle they are driving."

The route a chase may take is also a big factor.

Officers consider the time of day a pursuit would take place, the weather, the roads, terrain and traffic, and specific considerations such as nearby "schools and licensed premises".

Risk is also continually reviewed - if it appears to have increased, a pursuit can be stopped at any time.

BENJAMIN PEARSON A police officer with very short, dark hair. He has facial hair and is looking at the camera.BENJAMIN PEARSON
Former officer Ben Pearson described the crashes as heartbreaking

Former West Yorkshire Police roads policing officer Ben Pearson, who regularly appears on Channel 5's Police Interceptors, said officers undergo "extensive" pursuit training and "do not take it lightly" when a pursuit takes place.

Pearson said "planning and judgement" come into play when officers launch a pursuit, adding, for example, they "would not pursue a car into a pedestrian area or at school kick-out time".

He added: "For some time, people have called for a no-pursuit policy. However, if that took place, the UK would be absolutely crushed by crime and become lawless.

"The onus should be on the person making off."

If a serious or violent crime was suspected to have taken place, he explained, the public may wonder "why the vehicle was not stopped and taken out when it could have been".

"However, if it's a simple 'no insurance', people would ask why it is being pursued - the officer just doesn't know what's taken place until the vehicle is stopped," he said.

Pearson added: "It's absolutely heartbreaking for all involved when something bad happens. Family are left devastated and the officer is only doing their job."

A woman wearing a suit and blouse with a shaved head in what appears to be an office looks at the camera
Baroness Lowe said drivers - rather than the police - needed to take responsibility for their actions

Speaking to the BBC, Baroness Lowe said she was "satisfied" West Yorkshire Police officers were "putting the public first".

"I know the public would want the police to continue to pursue and to protect the public in the way they are doing," she added.

While Baroness Lowe said she does not have "any major concerns" about police protocols, she said she was concerned about "driver behaviour".

"Drivers need to take responsibility," she stated.

"You're getting into a killing machine, effectively… Drive safe and put the protection of the communities that you live in at the top of your agenda, as we are doing here in West Yorkshire."

West Yorkshire Police said it could not comment on the circumstances of the incidents while they remained under investigation by the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) and were the subject of active court proceedings.

However, a force spokesperson said it followed the "College of Policing's authorised professional practice, national strategy set by the National Police Chiefs' Council and applies the National Decision Model in relation to our use of police pursuit tactics".

These helped officers balance "catching offenders and preventing crime with public safety", they said, adding it was also legally required for the force to refer itself to the IOPC when someone died or was seriously injured in a pursuit.

Recent incidents

Leigh Ross, 39, of Prospect Place in Harrogate, appeared at Leeds Magistrates' Court on Monday charged with two counts of causing death by dangerous driving.

It came after West Yorkshire Police said officers were following a blue BMW 123D when it failed to stop and crashed into a white Volkswagen Scirocco at the junction of Gelderd Road and Lowfields Road just before 01:00 GMT on Sunday. The driver and passenger in the Volkswagen died.

Ross was also charged with two counts of causing death by driving a vehicle while uninsured, two counts of causing death by driving a vehicle while disqualified and two counts of causing death having taken a vehicle without consent.

On 11 November, a man in his 40s was left with "potentially life-threatening" injuries after he was struck by a silver BMW X1 on Easy Road at 12:35 GMT.

West Yorkshire Police said the crash occurred shortly after officers began pursuing the vehicle when it had failed to stop.

Květoslava Horvathova, 36, was walking on Beckett Street on 29 October when she was fatally struck by a black Vauxhall Corsa shortly after it failed to stop for police on Harehills Road.

Harry Gyamsie-Perah, of Coldcotes Garth, Leeds, has been charged with causing death by dangerous driving and is due to appear at Leeds Crown Court on 27 November.

West Yorkshire Police said the IOPC was investigating the circumstances of the pursuit, with the decision to follow the car authorised "a short time before the collision".

Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.