Man jailed for recording female colleagues using toilet

PA Media Outside of the Crown Court at Laganside in BelfastPA Media
Belfast Crown Court heard David O'Hara worked at the Mater Hospital in north Belfast where the majority of his victims also worked

A man, who secretly recorded female colleagues using the toilet at a hospital where they worked has been jailed for five months.

David O'Hara, 44, of Sea Coast Road in Limavady, had previously pleaded guilty to voyeurism by planting a camera in a unisex toilet.

He further admitted voyeurism by recording at least 23 females doing a private act in the toilet which was for his own sexual gratification.

Belfast Crown Court heard O'Hara worked at the Mater Hospital in north Belfast where the majority of his victims worked alongside him.

On October 3 2024, a female colleague went to the unisex staff toilet just after 11:00 GMT and while looking down she saw a "black cube with a coloured stripe on it and black coloured elastic band''.

The court was told she initially didn't know what it was and put it on the shelf in the toilet. She took a photograph of it and then discovered it had a memory card inside.

She then took the black cube to her department manager and handed it over to him. The court heard O'Hara then approached the manager and said the black cube belonged to him.

A prosecution barrister said: "He told the manager that it was the first time he placed the device under the sink. He later approached the woman who found the black cube and who he had been working with that day.

"He said to her 'Sorry' and she replied: 'Sorry for what?' He said: "The camera.'' She said: 'What camera?''

"O'Hara then pointed at the manager's office and said: 'The camera. It was mine. I am sorry' before he walked off.''

The court heard it was at that point the victim realised that what she found was a camera.

Hundreds of videos

Police attended the hospital that evening and the camera was seized.

Officers then went to O'Hara's home address and he was arrested for questioning. A search of his home uncovered USBs, a laptop and what appeared to be recording devices.

During his first interview on October 4, 2024, O'Hara accepted that the device was a small camera capable of recording and he had placed it in the toilet to spy on women for his own sexual gratification.

In the interview he told police there was a SD card in the camera and he would download the footage afterwards. He initially claimed it was the first time he had placed the camera in the toilet but later admitted it had been going on for a year.

The court heard O'Hara accepted that a folder on his laptop entitled 'Music' contained "hundreds of videos of people using the toilet'' but he denied sharing or distributing them and only kept recordings of females.

Inside the 'Music' file were subfolders with female names on them - the majority of whom were women he worked with.

In subsequent police interviews O'Hara was interviewed about 350 videos located on his laptop and 750 deleted videos and said he deleted videos if they were men and also deleted all videos that had no people in them.

He said he never watched the videos in live stream and confessed that his offending had started in 2021 and included a recording of a female colleague getting changed for yoga and the gym.

'Voyeuristic disorder'

In an interview with a probation officer, O'Hara admitted placing the camera in the toilet and said it had become an "addiction to him''.

The probation officer recorded the defendant "expressing remorse...and feelings of guilt and was more than sorry to his victims''.

A clinical psychologist who examined O'Hara said he believed he was suffering from a "voyeuristic disorder'', recommending the defendant participate in cognitive behaviour therapy with a female therapist.

Belfast Recorder, Judge Philip Gilpin, spoke of the "high level of harm" O'Hara's offending had caused to his victims.

Judge Gilpin said: "There was an element of direct harm caused to them. They were your work colleagues and they considered you to be their friend.

"You have breached their trust and that has caused deep harm and hurt to them.

"Some of them were undergoing deeply personal difficulties in their lives which your offending exacerbated.

"That harm lives with them to this day. Their trust in others has been shattered. Many experience anxiety, exacerbated stress, sleep disturbance, they have had to take time off work, in relation to public toilets they have to carry out checks in a way that no one should be expected to have to do.''

Judge Gilpin said he had given "much anxious thought'' to the appropriate sentence to be imposed given the culpability and harm were both "at a raised level'' in the case.

He said there was also the need for rehabilitation so that no further victims "would ever have to go through what your victims in this case have had to endure''.

Imposing a 15 month determinate custodial sentence, the Belfast Recorder told O'Hara that he would spend five months in custody followed by ten months on supervised licence on his release from prison.

O'Hara was placed on the sex offenders register for a period of seven years and he was made the subject of a restraining order and sexual offences prevention order, both for a period of five years.