Will the Scotland-England border landmark star ever shine?

Star of Caledonia Trust A computer-generated image of the Star of Caledonia landmark in a helix shape with prongs sticking out of it. People are gathered around on a grass moundStar of Caledonia Trust
The project at the Scotland-England border was first suggested about 25 years ago

A journey that started about a quarter of a century ago has been hit by a huge setback - just when it looked to be nearing its destination.

Everything appeared to be in place for the Star of Caledonia landmark artwork to finally be built near Gretna Green.

Then a major funder withdrew from the project at the Scotland-England border leaving the project needing to find £8m in order to proceed.

It is not the first blow it has had to deal with over the years since the idea first emerged in the wake of the foot-and-mouth outbreak of 2001.

The idea of the landmark - hoping to emulate the success of the Angel of the North in Gateshead - came from the late local businessman Alasdair Houston.

It was to celebrate the area's role as a "gateway" between Scotland and England - while also helping to boost the economy.

An early cost estimate for the scheme was about £3m.

Progress was slow but, by 2010, three international contenders had been selected to design the project - which was called, at the time, The Great Unknown.

Cecil Balmond, Ned Kahn and Wilkinson Eyre Architects were in contention, with the Sri Lanka-born designer Balmond ultimately selected.

Getty Images A pyre of animal carcasses being burned with smoke going high into the sky with snow covered fields around and houses behindGetty Images
The idea was formed in the wake of the foot-and-mouth outbreak which saw thousands of sheep and cattle culled and the carcasses burned

Author Ian Rankin described the winning design as "very forward-looking".

"It's quite futuristic, it isn't looking back, it isn't anything to do with the past," he said.

"It is not just a huge welcome to Scotland sign or a huge Saltire - it is quite revolutionary I think.

"I was reminded of almost like a twist of DNA - it had that kind of molecular thing going for it."

However, he said it was hard to look at big works of public sculpture because of their costs but added that people had to consider the longer-term potential to raise the profile of both Gretna and Dumfries and Galloway.

Getty Images The Angel of the North statue on top of a mound with wings outspreadGetty Images
The Star of Caledonia - if it gets built - would be much taller than the Angel of the North

By 2014, the price had reached £5m and Creative Scotland decided not to offer it £1m of support.

It said that was due to the failure to secure other public sector funding commitments.

That could have been a fatal blow, but hopes were revived a few years later.

In 2020, a funding pledge from renewable energy firm Community Windpower - combined with the backing of the Borderlands Growth Deal - put it firmly back on the agenda.

That was followed by a decision to scale back its size - from 40m (130ft) to 33m (110ft) - as the projected cost continued to rise.

Revised plans were approved last year by Dumfries and Galloway Council as the estimated price reached £12m.

Meanwhile, debate raged about the look of the artwork, with some describing it as "original" but others saying it was "truly awful".

However, things looked set for the project to go ahead - now with wider landscape work and a visitor hub included - with the hope of attracting 200,000 visitors a year.

However, a devastating financial blow was delivered when the news emerged that a major funder had pulled out, leaving a shortfall of £8m.

Star of Caledonia A computer-generated scene of a pathway around a small loch with a wooden visitor centre in the distanceStar of Caledonia
The plans hope to attract 200,000 visitors a year

A fundraising campaign to save the star has been launched and, meanwhile, the scheme has been put on hold.

The trust behind the plans has insisted it is not the end and has given itself some breathing space - until spring next year - to look for new backing.

The project has been here before but it faces a huge task in bridging the funding gap which has emerged in order to see the plans become reality.

The clock is ticking on whether the Star of Caledonia will ever get the chance to shine - or end up disappearing into a financial black hole.