New kidney research could have global implications

Getty Images A picture of a medical worker's hand which are in purple gloves holding a red tubes due to dialysis treatment. Getty Images
Bristol university's new research could have a global implication on how patients are treated

A "first-of-its-kind" study has found dialysis should not be the default treatment option for older people with kidney failure.

The research, led by the University of Bristol, found that managing symptoms in a less medicalised way may offer an alternative without compromising a person's quality and length of life.

Dialysis is a medical treatment that cleans a person's blood when they are experiencing kidney failure, but it often means spending hours in hospital every week and it carries risks of complications.

Project lead professor Fergus Caskey said: "Our findings could have global implications for how kidney failure is discussed and managed in older patients."

Caskey added that patients should be told the "pros and cons of both" treatments and "supported to make the choice that fits their priorities for care".

Rather than dialysis being automatically offered, experts have said the first randomised study of its kind in the world shows a structured programme of care for managing kidney failure can have similar results.

Caskey, a kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, said the study found "neither treatment option was superior to the other, but both provided similar overall length and quality of life".

He said, however, there was "no doubt" that dialysis was the "right option" for younger people with kidney failure.

"It is life-saving for younger people but it is a huge undertaking for patients," he said.

Dialysis involves going into hospital three times a week, usually for at least four hours at a time, which "can be very exhausting" for older patients, said Caskey.

Older people do not generally recover from kidney failure or come off dialysis.

Fergus Caskey, kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, is smiling at the camera. He has short dark hair and is wearing brown framed glasses and a pale blue shirt. He has two lanyards around his neck - one has University of Bristol branding and the other has NHS on it. He is sitting in an office setting next to a large Swiss cheese plant.
Fergus Caskey, kidney consultant at Bristol NHS Foundation Trust, said dialysis was "lifesaving for younger people"

The nine-year study involved almost 500 patients, with most being over the age of 80.

Many of them also had other health problems, including heart disease and cancer.

The study was randomised, which means participants were randomly allocated to one of two approaches - they were either prepared for dialysis or they were prepared for responsive management at home.

Over an average follow-up period of 4.5 years, the study found neither approach resulted in better outcomes when length and quality of life were considered together.

Participants in both groups were more likely to die from other causes than to require dialysis, reflecting the vulnerability and complex health needs of this population, experts said.

Lynn Watts is looking directly at the camera. She is wearing a black top and is sitting on a brown armchair. She has wavy white hair which is half-up in a claw clip.
Lynn Watts, from Kingswood, says her condition has "slowed her life down"

Lynn Watts, 77, from Kingswood in South Gloucestershire, said she thought the "end was near" when she was diagnosed with kidney failure almost five years ago.

She decided she would have dialysis if her symptoms progressed but she said she "didn't want three days taken out" of her life every week.

Watts became involved in the study in January 2024 and was randomly chosen as one of the patients offered an alternative to dialysis and her kidney function has been fairly stable since then.

"It's slowed my life down," she said. "I'm not running about and doing gardening... like I used to.

"I'm still alive and that's how I look at it."

There are 7.2 million people in the UK with some level of chronic kidney disease, mostly at the earliest stages, according to the charity Kidney Care UK.

Fiona Loud, from the charity, said the study offered the opportunity to look at the "balance of the treatment versus what you might value most... towards the end of your life".

She said she hoped the study would enable patients to make "balanced and informed choices which are flexible".

Follow BBC Bristol on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630.