Calls to relax 'Dickensian' Peak District house-buying rules

BBC Woman in green puffer jacket with blonde hair stood infront of a gate to a fieldBBC
After leaving briefly for university, Rachel Norman could not purchase an affordable home for her young family despite growing up in the area

There are calls for Peak District bosses to relax what some locals have called a "Dickensian" housing rule, which they say is hampering efforts to attract and keep young families living and working in the area.

A clause under the national park authority's legally binding planning rules dictates that prospective residents within many areas of the national park need a local connection to the village going back a decade - or a decade within the past 20 years - in order to access affordable housing there.

Several local authorities are calling for the "restrictive" rule to be relaxed amid concerns about sustaining the region's ageing population.

The park authority is now consulting on introducing more flexibility to the rule.

Areas within the national park such as the Derbyshire Dales have some of the oldest populations in England, with almost three in 10 residents aged 65 or over.

Meanwhile, it is not unusual for schools to have just a handful of children in a class.

The current rule is designed to try to protect housing for local needs and typically applies to new build housing on greenfield sites.

It means an individual or family wishing to occupy an affordable house in Castleton would need to have lived in Castleton, Edale, Hope with Aston, Bradwell or Peak Forest, or any combination of these places for a minimum of 10 years in the past 20 years.

While other national parks have similar policies stipulating a three or five-year connection, the Peak District's is stricter than most.

'We didn't tick a box'

Rachel Norman and her partner Billy now live in a semi-detached house in Hope with their two young children.

But the 34-year-old says the stress of the process of acquiring their much-loved family home left a lasting impact.

Having grown up in neighbouring Chinley, Rachel left briefly for university in Sheffield before returning to Derbyshire in 2015 to set up the cafe in Hope she now runs with her partner, who is from Matlock.

They spent the majority of the next decade renting in the area while looking for an affordable house to buy.

When one finally came on the market within their price range at the end of 2024, she was told by the national park that her family was blocked from consideration because she fell foul of the 10-year clause by seven months.

Woman with blonde plait sat on sofa in her living room looking through forms on a coffee table
Rachel and her partner wrote a personal letter to national leaders

"We were very close to 10 years, so we were quite confident with our background of being local people," she said.

"We've got the business and two kids so we've got we've got strong connections there to the local community and we'd been trying to buy a house for nine years... we were like, '[we are] ticking all these boxes, why can't we get it?'."

She and her partner set about filling out an extensive amount of paperwork demonstrating local connection and need, including bank statements, utility bills and evidence of GP registration for each of the past nine-and-a-half years they had lived in the area.

They also submitted a personal letter stressing their local connections, which was signed by a number of local councillors and supporters.

"We said where we've come from, that we live and work here, we've got a local business, you know, we're providing local people with jobs like 10 local people.

"We organise lots of community events, then we just had two young children as well, one who's already at school."

In response, they received what Rachel describes as a "straightforward" email.

"It just said, 'at present, you do not qualify as you do not meet the local qualification provisions'," she said.

"I just felt unseen because they hadn't addressed anything that we said about our personal circumstances... we haven't ticked a box.

"We were so close to getting a house, we'd been trying for years and years and then it was just taken away."

Rachel was left with no option but to hope another clause attached to the property would work in their favour. It stipulated that if the house was on the market for three months without any offers, the 10-year requirement would be reduced to five.

"I think because no-one else fit the clause, because it's so restrictive... we got lucky."

The family finally moved in August 2025, but Rachel attributes a shingles diagnosis that summer to the stress of the process.

Phil Mulligan, chief executive of Peak District National Park Authority, said he had sympathy with Rachel, acknowledging the system was "complicated and drawn out".

However, he added the rule was "there for a reason."

"We're in a national park and we are constrained... it is everyone's aspiration to live here, but we can't accommodate all those aspirations," he said.

"What I would ask Rachel to reflect on is, when her children come to an age... will there be any houses for them? Yes, if we maintain these policies."

Elderly man in blue jumper stood infront of stone wall
Derbyshire Dales District Council, where Peter O'Brien represents Hathersage, supports relaxing the rule

The stereotypical image of residents of places like the Peak District, home to some of the most picturesque villages in England, are of a resident population typically resistant to change - especially when it comes to housing and adding to its population.

But as the Peak Park authority approaches the final stages of completing a review of its Local Plan, there are plenty of local voices that have emerged calling for it to relax its approach on who gets to live there.

Peter O'Brien, one of the councillors representing Hathersage where house prices average at about half a million pounds, has been arguing for a relaxation of what he calls a "Dickensian" rule for a number of years.

He says he has seen young people regularly moving away to Chesterfield or Sheffield because of the rule, despite growing up in areas like his.

"Over the past 10 years [the Peak Park has] lost almost 20% of our young people under 25, that's what's happening to our community. They're being suffocated by this really restrictive planning policy," he said.

"We're sleepwalking into a situation where our villages have no future, they have no sustainable future, they have no young people. Our schools have already lost half their roll.

"The national park have got to understand that times are changing, families are much more mobile these days.

"We're not saying abandon the policy, but it needs to be much more flexible."

He also says the authority should build more affordable homes, stating that it is a "complete myth" that areas like his do not want new housing.

"We're desperate. We haven't had a new house built in Hathersage for 10 years."

Man in black puffer jacket stood infront of trees
Phil Mulligan says the authority is exploring the idea of introducing more flexibility around the rule

The Peak District Rural Housing Association, several parish councils such as Hope, Tideswell and Edale, along with High Peak and Derbyshire Dales district council, all put forward concerns about the rule as part of the consultation process for the Peak Park authority's Local Plan review.

Derbyshire Dales District Council told the BBC there was a need to stress "the importance of striking the right balance between protecting local housing opportunities and ensuring communities remain viable in the long term".

"There may be merit in considering whether a shorter period - such as five years - could achieve the same objective of prioritising local people while providing greater flexibility for younger households, working families and those contributing to the local economy," it said.

High Peak told the consultation that "the current 10-year local connection requirement is too restrictive and should be reduced".

Some parish councils, like Holme Valley, also argued for exceptions to the rule for "essential workers" who do not meet the current criteria but "could be able to carry out essential work within a community, such as community nurses, care workers... currently they are priced out of housing and rentals."

'More nuance needed'

Phil Mulligan told the BBC that evidence gathered from the local plan consultation suggested the authority needed to be more flexible around the rule.

"We are actually asking if it should be relaxed, so you maintain it if you are the first occupant, but for subsequent occupants going on to sell a house, that might be reduced to a five-year local connection," he said.

But he said he disagreed with the idea that the rule was potentially damaging.

"Because of the unique geography of this national park where we're surrounded by urban areas, where people can work but still travel from the national park, we can't meet the aspirations of all those who want to live here," he said.

"What we have to focus on is the absolute need, those in most need. We have to... protect that [affordable] housing stock.

"If we then go and remove those... restrictions, those houses get sold on the open market, they get expanded and then there isn't the ongoing stock for new, young families."

But Rachel thinks while the rule may be designed to prioritise local people and keep young families like hers, her case demonstrates it has the opposite effect.

At the very least, she argues that more nuance is needed in the park authority's approach to who qualifies as "local" and who does not.

"We love Hope and we wanted to stay in Hope," she said.

"But if we do ever want to sell in the future then then it's going to be difficult... it's going to be very restrictive."

Listen to BBC Radio Derby on Sounds and follow BBC Derby on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210.