Price defends Welsh budget after business groups voice concerns

Getty Images Welsh government minister Adam Price raises his right hand while speaking in front of a blue backdropGetty Images
Adam Price says overall spending on economic development is rising

Enterprise minister Adam Price has defended the Welsh government's draft budget after some of the country's leading business groups warned it does not do enough to support growth and investment in the private sector.

The Confederation of British Industry (CBI) said firms would be disappointed by a budget which "does little to tackle the high costs and uncertainty" facing businesses.

Price insisted ministers were "firing up the economy" and argued critics were focusing on individual budget lines rather than an overall increase in spending.

He said the budget represented a first step in a longer-term plan to reshape the Welsh economy, including through a new development agency.

"I think we're building the tools in the toolbox that we need," he said.

Price pointed to £22m for the new Welsh development agency next year, and said spending on core economic development activities would increase by around 30%, from £52m to £70m.

He also highlighted increased investment in renewable energy, which he argued could eventually help Wales turn its natural resources into a competitive advantage for businesses through lower energy costs.

Getty Images A woman in a red coat walks in front of a large shop window, the window is filled with "Winter Sale" notices and a sign that reads "Up To 70% Off"Getty Images
The Federation of Small Businesses says the draft budget raises concerns about Welsh government support for firms

The CBI welcomed detailed commitments to establish the new Welsh Innovation and Development Agency and the £1.5bn capital funding package for housing, but said ministers needed to go further on business rates, planning reform, skills and transport infrastructure.

"Businesses will be left disappointed by a draft budget that does little to tackle the high costs and uncertainty that are undermining confidence and holding back investment in the projects, jobs and skills needed to revitalise the Welsh economy," said CBI Wales deputy director Katie Spackman.

She said firms would "welcome the detailed funding commitments to establish a new Welsh Innovation and Development Agency" and wanted further detail about "how the government will tackle high business rates in the finalised budget in February".

The Federation of Small Businesses (FSB), meanwhile, warned that cuts to business support programmes risked making it harder for small businesses to invest, recruit and grow at a time when economic growth remains weak.

"This draft budget raises serious questions about the future of business support in Wales," said FSB Head of Wales, Joshua Miles.

"The decision to halve Business Wales funding, alongside wider cuts to business support programmes, is a significant concern at a time when growth in the Welsh economy is weak."

Getty Images In a pink jacket and glasses, Elin Jones smiles as she pours a pint of lagerGetty Images
Finance minister Elin Jones poured a pint to announce a cut to some business rates, but there are calls for the Welsh government to broaden the support

Asked about the criticism, Price said he had already spoken to the CBI and planned further discussions with business representative groups.

"Sometimes you've got to have a qualification in Excel to understand your way around all of the detail," he said.

He argued that while some individual programmes were being reduced or reorganised, the overall level of spending on economic development was increasing.

"We're streamlining some of that in readiness for the new development agency, but the important thing is what's happening at the global level. "We're increasing the level of revenue expenditure going into core economic development," he said.

Getty Images A close-up image of the orange cables that connect black racks of computer hardware inside a data centreGetty Images
The Welsh government is developing a data centre policy, after calling-in the planning decision on a new data centre in Cardiff

Asked about the government's stance on data centres, after a proposed Cardiff development was called in by ministers, Price said the government wanted to establish a policy that would avoid some of the problems seen elsewhere.

"The Wales of the future and the Wales of now needs digital infrastructure, including data centres," he said.

However, he said ministers wanted developments to be located in areas where energy and grid capacity were available and to avoid public opposition driven by concerns about water use and power consumption.

"We're creating a 'Made in Wales' version" of the UK government's data centre covenant," Price added, arguing that a clearer framework would support investors and local communities.

One of the sharpest criticisms from business groups has centred on business rates, after an announcement earlier this year that rates for some firms will be cut next year.

Getty Images Protestors in warm clothes hold up home-made signs that oppose data centres in ScotlandGetty Images
Protestors took to the streets in Scotland to oppose data centres, and Price said Wales needed to learn from the experience of other countries

The Welsh Retail Consortium joined the CBI in calling for greater clarity on promised support before the final budget, while hospitality representatives have warned that some firms could end up paying more despite the government's wider reforms.

Price said the draft budget did not contain the final position on business rates and suggested further support remained possible.

"We've always said on business rates, where we can help we will," he said, adding that the finance secretary had already indicated that further announcements could be made when the final budget is published.

Price also defended cuts to employability programmes, another area highlighted by business groups as a concern.

He said the Welsh government had concluded that traditional approaches were failing to tackle rising levels of young people not in education, employment or training.

Instead, ministers want to focus on creating jobs and then introducing recruitment and training to according to demand.

"We've got to fire up the economy to create the jobs," he said.