MP raises concerns over asbestos in ageing schools

Getty Images Asbestos warning signGetty Images
Hundreds of schools past their structural lifespan may contain large amounts of asbestos

An MP has urged the government to develop a plan to deal with hundreds of school buildings that campaigners fear could contain large amounts of asbestos.

James Naish, Labour MP for Rushcliffe in Nottinghamshire, has called for an overarching strategic solution because the county has "such a prevalence" of buildings constructed using a particular method called CLASP.

CLASP, which stands for Consortium of Local Authorities Special Programme, was a building system that used a prefabricated, lightweight steel frame to meet demand for new school buildings.

Naish said: "The longer term issue is that there are hundreds of schools that are going to need be rebuilt in the not too distant future."

A Health and Safety Executive spokesperson said the presence of asbestos did not automatically present a risk to health.

The risk arises when asbestos containing materials are damaged or disturbed and fibres are released, they added.

"We engage regularly with the Department for Education, whose published guidance emphasises the importance of identifying and managing asbestos in schools to protect staff, pupils, students and visitors."

Naish fears the problem is on the same scale as schools built with reinforced autoclaved aerated concrete (RAAC), a flawed structural concrete which led to closures of schools across the country.

He raised his concern in Parliament about CLASP earlier this month, saying: "These buildings were constructed in the mid-to-late 20th century, using systems that offered quick and economical solutions to the demands of their time.

"Many are now well beyond their intended working lives. They present significant challenges involving structural deterioration, asbestos, accessibility, insulation, heating and maintenance."

Responding to the debate, children and families minister Josh MacAlister said the government had set out a 10-year plan to renew schools and colleges and was increasing capital spending over the course of this parliament

Hank Roberts Vintage photograph of workmen in a building site which has a steel frame of a buildingHank Roberts
CLASP used steel frames bolted together and filled with panels to allow quick and cheap construction

CLASP was developed in Nottinghamshire in the 1950s, the same time period as RAAC, but had a limited lifespan of 40 years.

It used lightweight steel frame units which could be bolted together to create buildings up to four storeys and was especially popular for schools in areas with mining subsidence like Nottinghamshire, Derbyshire and County Durham.

Hank Roberts, a former president of the National Education Union, and a health and safety representative for more than 40 years, said: "After the war they were the prefabs and obviously they wanted to get things done as cheaply as possible, so a CLASP school is like a prefabricated one with lots of panels for the walls and the panels containing asbestos.

"Asbestos is not flammable and it's a very good insulator. At the time it was viewed as something of a wonder material.

"While there are different types of asbestos, they all have that same property in that they have very minute, really thin fibres and they can escape very readily, get into the atmosphere and they get into people's throats and lungs and, decades later, cause cancers like mesothelium."

James Naish MP
James Naish MP said the government and local authorities needed to come up with a strategy to deal with the issue

Naish said about 750 of the approximately 3,500 CLASP buildings across the UK were in Nottinghamshire.

Figures from a 2008 report by Nottinghamshire County Council also showed nearly 250 CLASP projects in Derbyshire, more than 140 in County Durham and hundreds of others scattered around the UK.

Naish said this represented a "significant problem for our region".

"For Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire, we need an overarching, strategic solution, because we have such a prevalence of these buildings," he added.

"It's not just a case of a few here and a few there, there are hundreds of these things.

"I've started that process, but it needs local authorities using their abilities, councillors, MPs. All levels need to be talking about the situation in Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire," he said.

"It needs a bottom-up push from schools to emphasise the issues they are facing.

"But it does need that top down strategic approach which I hope I can work with the department to develop."

Alamy Demolition of CLASP building at Nottinghamshire County Council's County Hall in 2017Alamy
A CLASP extension of Nottinghamshire's County Hall was demolished in 2017 and asbestos removed

Charles Pickles, who ran an asbestos management firm and has campaigned for higher safety standards in the industry since 2019, added: "The CLASP buildings were built on a design life in the 1960s and 70s of 40 years. So that, by definition, means that they are past their design life.

"So the question is, are all these materials, which pass their design life in good condition?

"We know from the Department of Education's own research that there's a massive maintenance backlog across the schools estate

"And while the accepted wisdom is the asbestos is safe unless disturbed, what are the chances of these materials, somehow managing to remain in pristine condition, for 40 years, in buildings, full of teenage children?

"The idea is untenable."

The exact scale of the issue is difficult to judge as there is no central database on asbestos in buildings, he said.

While the risk to individuals in schools is low, he believes the issue is one that needs more attention.

James Walker-Gurley, Nottinghamshire County Council's cabinet member for economic development and asset management, said: "This year alone, we committed £46m to ensure our children learn in safe, modern, fit-for-purpose environments, partnering closely with Arc Partnership to manage our estate, including our older, challenging, legacy CLASP buildings.

"We are entirely aligned with local leaders that our schools urgently need the capital funding we were originally expecting.

"When reductions from central government caused us to temporarily pause several key rebuilding schemes earlier this year, it created genuine concern.

"Thankfully, the Department for Education have responded to our request for additional funding and clarification on future funding and we are currently in negotiation and discussion about the details of our various building projects and funding streams."

The Department for Education has been approached for comment.

Listen to BBC Radio Nottingham on Sounds and follow BBC Nottingham on Facebook, on X, or on Instagram. Send your story ideas to eastmidsnews@bbc.co.uk or via WhatsApp on 0808 100 2210.