Morecambe Bay tops NHS list for patient data access breaches

NHS A yellow-and-green NHS ambulance parked outside the Emergency Department entrance of Royal Lancaster Infirmary, with a second ambulance visible in the background beneath a covered drop-off area. The hospital building has beige brick walls and large windows, and the scene is lit by daylight.NHS
The University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay which run Royal Lancaster Infirmary had 242 incidents between 2021 and 2026 according to new figues

A hospital trust has said it has "zero tolerance" for staff snooping on patients' data after figures showed it had the highest number of incidents of it in the country.

The University Hospitals of Morecambe Bay NHS Foundation Trust had 242 incidents between 2021 and 2026, the Press Association's Freedom of Information (FOI) requests showed.

The trust has not yet revealed what action it has taken over the incidents.

It follows recent high-profile cases of NHS staff inappropriately accessing patient data including those who looked at the medical records of victims of the Southport knife attacks, which yoga teacher Leanne Lucas saying it left her feeling "violated".

Another hospital trust in the north-west of England - the Wrightington, Wigan & Leigh NHS Foundation Trust - was fourth in the FOI responses list, with 194 incidents in the five-year period.

West Suffolk NHS Foundation Trust disclosed 213 instances and Northumbria Healthcare NHS Foundation Trust recorded 195.

Patient advocates said the breaches "erode trust" in organisations involved and the wider NHS, with a "lack of transparency" deepening the damage.

More than 3,000 incidents of staff inappropriately accessing patient data were disclosed by 79 NHS hospital and ambulance trusts in England following the FOI requests submitted to 143 trusts.

Leanne Lucas, who has long wavy dark hair, and is wearing a white T-shirt with a circular logo with the catchphrase 'Let's Be Blunt' on the front. She is standing in a kitchen looking into the camera with a determined expression.
Southport attack victim Leanne Lucas said she was "horrified" by the "inexcusable morbid curiosity" of NHS staff accessing her medical records

But the actual number of incidents will be higher as other trusts declined to provide exact data and instead said there had been "fewer than five" in a particular year, to avoid a risk of individuals being identified.

Trusts must report breaches that could pose a risk to a patient's rights to data protection regulator the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO) within 72 hours.

The figures come after the ICO revealed last week it had received more than 300 reports this year of staff looking at records with no good reason, inspecting records of people they know or sharing information with others.

Anna Telfer, chief nursing officer at Morecambe Bay, said the trust had a "zero-tolerance approach" to breaches.

The BBC has asked the trust what action has been taken over the incidents and for more details on how many staff members made inappropriate access to patients medical records, including if this was a small number of staff making repeated breaches.

The trust has yet to respond.

A Northumbria Healthcare spokesperson said that in 2024, it introduced a system to proactively monitor access each month which has reduced the number of incidents.

Supplied A composite image of the late Barnaby Webber, Grace O'Malley-Kumar and Ian CoatesSupplied
Fifteen people have been sacked for inappropriately accessing medical records of the Nottingham attacks victims

Matthew Hopkins, acute and ambulance network director at the NHS Alliance, said any misuse of records was "a serious breach of trust".

He said strong data governance was "essential" as digital technology becomes increasingly central to patient care.

"Maintaining public confidence in the use of patient data is crucial," he added.

ICO chief executive Paul Arnold said he had written to hundreds of health leaders across the UK calling for an end to "unacceptable" breaches.

He described the figures as "deeply concerning" and said organisations needed "effective access controls, monitoring, training and consistent action when things go wrong".

'Inexcusable'

Recent examples of high-profile incidents include dozens of health workers found to have looked at the records of victims of the 2024 Southport attack, which left three girls dead and 10 others injured.

Lucas, who was the instructor at the Taylor Swift-themed dance event and is one of the three adult survivors, has said she was "devastated and horrified" by the "inexcusable morbid curiosity".

Grace O'Malley-Kumar, Barnaby Webber, both 19, and grandfather Ian Coates, 65, were stabbed to death in the street by Valdo Calocane in Nottingham in 2023.

Rachel Power, chief executive of the Patients Association, said cases like these "erode trust, not only in the trust involved but in the wider NHS".

"Patients need confidence that strong safeguards are in place, that inappropriate access will be detected and acted on without delay, and that they will be the first to know, not the last, when their confidentiality has been breached," she added.

Listen to the best of BBC Radio Lancashire on Sounds, watch BBC North West Tonight on BBC iPlayer and follow BBC Lancashire on Facebook, X and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.