Ferries boss says Ferguson shipyard should not get new CalMac contracts

Getty Images A large red white and black ferry moored beside a large building with Ferguson Marine on the sideGetty Images
Unions say Ferguson workers are "blameless" for the ferries controversy and the firm should be supported as it tries to move on

A direct award of new CalMac ferries contracts to the nationalised Ferguson shipyard is "not the right thing to do", according to the boss of Scotland's state-owned ferries procurement agency.

CMAL chief executive Kevin Hobbs told MSPs he was "100%" against giving the yard new work for two small ferries, despite a pledge by SNP ministers in March.

He said delays and overspends during its construction of two much larger CalMac ships were well known, and there was a risk the problems could be repeated.

Ferguson Marine said it had a proud shipbuilding record that stretched back far longer than recent controversies, while the GMB union said CMAL was itself responsible for many of the problems.

Transport Secretary Stephen Flynn, giving evidence at the same session of Holyrood's transport committee, said the government remained committed to directly awarding the contracts to Ferguson Marine.

"I believe it is absolutely right that we put our confidence in Ferguson's as the last commercial shipbuilder on the Clyde to be able to deliver these vessels for the island communities to ensure that we have resilience within the network, the resilience that they deserve," he said.

Hobbs was being questioned about delays affecting the second phase of the Small Vessels Replacement Programme which involves two, or possibly three, small electric ferries for the Sound of Harris and Sound of Barra.

He replied that preliminary work was complete but the project was being held up while ministers considered ways in which the contract could be awarded directly.

He said he believed a direct award was not currently lawful, but that it might be possible next year due to planned changes to the governance structure of CMAL.

But he then made it clear that he and CMAL's board of directors were opposed to the move, and would have to be instructed to so by Scottish ministers, who are CMAL's sole shareholder.

Kevin Hobbs told MSPs building ferries at Ferguson's was "not the right thing to do"

He said: "While we want to see that shipyard survive, we do not believe building ferries there is the right thing to do for the island communities."

He said he wanted the "near neighbour" Ferguson shipyard, which is just a few minutes walk from CMAL's offices in Port Glasgow, to survive.

But he said he was worried that poor value for money and delays that blighted construction of MV Glen Sannox and MV Glen Rosa would be repeated.

"Commercially I do not believe, and we do not believe as a board, that we ought to to be building ferries there at this point in time," he added.

A letter from Hobbs to Transport Scotland, which has since been made public, says direct award of the new small vessels is "problematic at best and folly at worst".

He said choosing to build ferries in Scotland would be a "political decision" and that CMAL wanted to have an open tendering process involving international bidders.

Awards to overseas shipyards

CMAL has not awarded a shipbuilding contract to a Scottish or UK shipyard since 2015, but has placed multiple orders with firms in Turkey and Poland.

The first phase of the small vessels replacement programme, involving seven small vessels, was awarded to Gdansk-based Remontowa, which undercut Ferguson's on price even though the Scottish yard's bid was praised by CMAL for its quality.

UK shipbuilders says overseas yards benefit from cheaper labour costs and better state support, and argue that procurement model should take into account the wider benefits of placing orders with UK firms.

Plans to directly award the small ferries contract to Ferguson Marine were announced in March, a few weeks before the Holyrood election, by then transport secretary Fiona Hyslop.

At the same time former economy secretary Kate Forbes revealed plans to directly award the yard work on two other vessels - a marine protection ship and a research vessel, subject to the necessary due diligence.

Forbes said it would benefit island communities and the Inverclyde community as well as enabling the recovery of Ferguson's, which is the last surviving commercial shipyard on the River Clyde.

CMAL A concept rendering of a small double ended ferry with hills in the background CMAL
A concept drawing of the new small electric ferries being constructed under the Small Vessels Replacement Programme

Flynn told the transport committee the government remained committed to supporting Ferguson Marine through direct awards.

He said: "I am extremely confident in the yard and its ability to deliver and I think it's fundamentally important that the Scottish government delivers a future for Ferguson's and delivers for the islanders."

Graeme Thomson, chief executive of Ferguson Marine, said the shipyard had a long history that stretched back much further than the recent difficulties.

He said: "Glen Sannox is now in service with Glen Rosa due to follow shortly and we have learned hard lessons from that programme.

"Today's Ferguson Marine has new leadership, stronger governance, greater programme management control and a skilled workforce ready to deliver."

He added that the firm was providing skilled jobs in Port Glasgow and keeping shipbuilding skills alive on the Clyde.

"Our recent past does not define our future and our focus remains on showing that our yard can and will build Scotland's ferries well, on time and to budget," he said.

Scotland's 'ferry factory'

Press Association A worker in a blue Ferguson Marine boiler suit watches a large ferry on the  ClydePress Association
Unions say Ferguson workers are "blameless" for the ferries controversy and the firm should be supported as it tries to move on

GMB shop stewards at Ferguson's, Alex Logan and Kenny Meechan, said they were shocked and "extremely disappointed" by Hobbs' remarks.

Regional organiser Robert Deavy said CMAL shared responsibility for the "two calamitous ferry contracts" which had harmed the shipyard's reputation, and it should be helping the "blameless workforce" rather than talking it down.

He said: "People have short memories but Ferguson's built a third of the current CalMac fleet and was once, not that long ago, Scotland's ferry factory.

"With the right leadership and proper investment, it can again deliver a steady stream of first-class small ferries for Scotland's islanders."

Ferguson's has previously successfully built three small hybrid power ferries for CalMac, which are still in service and are similar to the new small ferries.

While CMAL has been strongly critical of management at Ferguson's in the past, it has often found itself accused of being partly responsible for what went wrong.

CMAL is believed to have been the driving force behind the choice of the LNG dual fuel propulsion system, which added complexity to the construction of Glen Sannox and Glen Rosa.

The former owners of Ferguson's also claimed the construction of the ships ran into difficulties because CMAL launched the tender without doing sufficient preliminary work to establish that the specifications were feasible.

CMAL has denied that, saying the problems arose mainly because of poor management decisions at the shipyard, and it refused to accept the yard's claims for extra costs.

The stalemate eventually led to the firm going into administration in 2019, and it was later nationalised with design challenges, delays and cost rises continuing under public ownership.