Failings contributed to arson attack deaths, family tells inquest
Family photosThe family of a mother who was murdered in an arson attack along with her four youngest children have said failings by police and local authorities contributed to their deaths, an inquest heard.
Michelle Pearson, 37, died nearly two years after her home in Walkden, Salford, was firebombed on 11 December 2017, killing her four youngest children.
The inquest at Bolton Coroner's Court heard Michelle had called police several times and told social workers she wanted to move before the murders.
Final submissions from lawyers for the family, Greater Manchester Police and others were heard earlier. GMP said the evidence did not support that their inaction had probably caused or contributed to the deaths.
The murders came after a feud involving mother-of-six Michelle's eldest son.
Zak Bolland, 26, his accomplice David Worrall, 28, and Bolland's girlfriend, Courtney Brierley, 20, were all jailed over the fatal attack in December 2017.
'Missed opportunities'
Anna Morris KC, representing the Pearson family, said the ultimate culpability for the "heinous murders" was with the three perpetrators.
But she said there had been "missed opportunities" and "cumulative failures" from authorities to stop and assess the risk the family were under from Bolland.
"This was not an arson attack out of the blue by an unknown perpetrator," Morris added.
The family believe a strategy meeting by Salford Council social workers should have been held to deal with the risk when Michelle presented as homeless through risk of violence. They say she should have been rehoused.
They also say police failed to investigate and intervene after Bolland smashed her windows and set fire to her wheelie bin in the days before the fatal attack.
He had walked free from a police station after giving a 12-minute "no comment" interview when Greater Manchester Police decided to take no further action, the inquest heard.
At the time, Bolland was on a "last chance" from a judge and serving a suspended jail sentence – and should have been arrested for breaking his bail conditions.
PA MediaThe court heard that in the hours before the fatal attack, Bolland had again turned up on Michelle's doorstep and threatened to "do the house".
The inquest heard police were called but believed that Bolland, who lived 350 yards away, was making "empty threats" and so did not arrest him.
Officers instead went back to the station to complete paperwork and two hours later Bolland returned and firebombed the house.
Morris said these failings probably contributed to the deaths in the arson attack.
Fiona Barton KC, representing GMP, said the force had recognised their failings, but the evidence did not support that their inaction had probably caused or contributed to the deaths.
Barton said the coroner should not "speculate" as to what might have happened if police had tried to arrest Bolland after Michelle called police on the night of the attack.
GMP admitted no attempt had been made to arrest Bolland, at the "most significant opportunity" to safeguard the family, which may have deterred him.
But Barton said Bolland, who had taken drink and drugs, was not deterred by seeing a police car outside the house. She said he had returned with petrol bombs once the car had left.
'Pure speculation'
Barton told the hearing that response officers making decisions to close investigations now faced strategic oversight and more support and direction.
"In 2017, which was when sadly this tragic event took place, GMP was a failing force under special measures," she added. "It is in a very different place today."
Sam Green, representing seven GMP officers who had dealt with incidents at the house, said any failings of officers could not be said to have probably contributed to the fatal arson attack.
Green said Bolland had been told by a judge he was "drinking in the last chance saloon" but continued to commit crime, adding that to suggest police action would have prevented him carrying out the attack was "pure speculation".
Bolland and Worrall were both jailed for life for murder in 2018 and told they would serve a minimum of 40 and 37 years respectively.
Brierley was jailed for 21 years for manslaughter.
The coroner will give his conclusions on 27 November.
Listen to the best of BBC Radio Manchester on Sounds and follow BBC Manchester on Facebook, X, and Instagram. You can also send story ideas via Whatsapp to 0808 100 2230.
