GP practice rated inadequate for safety

Google An exterior shot of Atrium Health Centre during the day. It is a modern building and its front comprises three large, curved, off-white panels layered on top of one another. Metallic lettering reading "Health Centre" sits above the front entrance. Google
Atrium Health Centre in Dorchester was rated "requires improvement" overall by the Care Quality Commission

A GP practice has had its rating for safety cut from "good" to "inadequate" by the health watchdog.

Atrium Health Centre, in Dorchester, was rated "requires improvement" overall after a Care Quality Commission (CQC) inspection in May.

Inspectors found 88 test results had not been opened or acted on, and records for three patients marked "do not attempt resuscitation" with no evidence it had been discussed with them.

A spokesperson for the practice said the resuscitation records were down to "an administrative coding error".

It said the report did not give a "fair or balanced picture", and it had raised concerns about how the assessment was conducted and called for a formal ratings review.

The challenge had already led to several findings being amended, a section being removed and some scores being raised, it said.

The practice, which serves about 6,600 patients and also runs Crossways Surgery, was rated "good" in every area at its last inspection in 2016.

The CQC served warning notices on it in June over safe care and treatment, premises and equipment, and governance.

Its report said the practice had not spotted the resuscitation coding problem itself, and did not provide evidence by the deadline that the affected records had been reviewed.

Inspectors also found urgent tasks dating back to April, including arranging blood tests, that had not been done. The CQC said it had previously raised the issue with the practice.

An emergency steroid medicine had been recorded as present for three months but was not in stock, and there was no evidence of criminal record checks for two clinical staff who had worked there for more than five years, the report said.

The practice said five patients referred for paramedic home visits had been affected by the coding error, and their resuscitation decisions were correct.

It said the template had been fixed and all five records updated.

The practice said the 88 unopened test results had arrived on the afternoon of Friday 15 May, four days before the inspection.

They were being dealt with within its 48-working-hour target, it said, and added that a review found no patient came to harm.

It also said it had since strengthened daily monitoring of results and clinical tasks.

The missing steroid medicine had been reordered, but a "human error" meant its non-arrival was missed, the practice said, and acknowledged its checks should have identified this.

The spokesperson said: "We take patient safety extremely seriously and welcome independent scrutiny.

"However, we are concerned that some of the CQC's findings, without the appropriate background, could cause unnecessary anxiety among our patients.

"We recognise improvements were needed and have not sought to avoid responsibility for them."

The practice said it had made substantial improvements since May, including to staffing and emergency equipment checks, and recruited two more GPs.

It said patients should continue to attend appointments as normal.