'Hole in the ground' fear during ex-library site sale

Aisha Iqbal/BBC A group of four people standing in front of a piece of wasteland which is fenced off from the main roadAisha Iqbal/BBC
Campaigners say the former Ian Clough Hall site has become an "eyesore" over the last three years

People in Baildon are demanding answers over the future of their former library site after the council put the land up for sale.

Ian Clough Hall, which housed Baildon Library and other community facilities, was demolished in 2023. Developer McCarthy Stone had planned to build 47 retirement apartments on the site but pulled out last year.

Bradford Council confirmed the land is set to be sold as part of its "asset disposal programme and medium-term financial strategy".

Locals shared concerns the "eyesore" site may further deteriorate, with fears a promised replacement library funded by the sale could be at risk.

Conservative councillor David Ford, who represents Baildon, was granted a scrutiny review of the sale, which was drawn up by officers as a "delegated" decision without the need for approval by the council's executive.

A cross-party panel of Bradford councillors will now "call in" and examine the decision to put the land on the market.

Ford said he and other campaigners wanted a "significant investigation" rather than the authority just "waving it through", comparing the location to the stalled Westfield shopping centre development that left a gap in Bradford for years.

"It's a hole in the ground, just like the hole in the ground in Bradford many years ago that everyone talked about," he added.

LDRS A 1970s style office/leisure building built in the municipal modernist style. It has extra long, narrow vertical windows in a grid style all on every side. Pillars at the front make it look like it is on stilts. It is plain in style, with hardly any decorative features apart from a crest an block lettering spelling its name. There is also signage identifying it as Baildon library.LDRS
The Ian Clough Hall, named after the Baildon-born mountaineer who died in 1970, housed a library and community facilities

Ford said Baildon had also lost youth facilities and other community space when the hall came down.

The old library's lending section has been operating out of a former shop unit, with its other collections thought to be in storage.

"My big concern is that the library doesn't have a proper facility and never will except for the old shop premises it's currently using," Ford said.

He said campaigners "fully understand" that the council had to balance the books, but said "Baildon has been promised a decent library" and instead had a "hole in the ground".

The decision report for the Ian Clough Hall site, signed off by senior council officers, says the authority did consider an alternative option to "retain the property and continue to manage as part of the council owned non-operational estate" but ultimately decided to sell it.

Aisha Iqbal/BBC Four people standing on some steps outside a Yorkshire stone fronted building. A large black sign above them has the words 'The Baildon Club' in gold lettering on it.Aisha Iqbal/BBC
Campaigners are keen to see the former Baildon Club revamped to house a new library

In 2022, the then Labour administration at Bradford Council approved a plan for the nearby Baildon Club building to become the home of a new library, with the proceeds of the site sale going towards funding it.

Earlier this year, the local authority told Baildon Town Council the club building was in "significantly poorer condition than originally anticipated" and overall project costs would go up.

The project was paused, with further investigations "expected to take several months to complete".

"Bradford Council remains fully committed to delivering this project and to ensuring that the community has access to a sustainable and accessible library service," the council said.

However, campaigners said the site sale had created further uncertainty.

Councillor Debbie Davies, also a Baildon Conservative representative, said: "It's an eyesore as it is at the moment.

" I get contacted by residents concerned about the state of it. We just want to see some action going forward."

Aisha Iqbal/BBC A piece of overgrown wasteland, with a wire fence in front of it. In the background is a church building with a clock tower, and housing to the left.Aisha Iqbal/BBC
The 0.95 former Ian Clough Hall site is being put up for sale by Bradford Council

Geoffrey Shaw Champion, from the Baildon Civic and Historical Society, said: "The Baildon Club goes back to the 18th Century, it's a very old building and it's in a prominent position.

"We'd like it to be refurbished and used as a community centre rather than, as it is at the minute, being left to decay."

He added: "I know that Bradford has this enormous debt and my worry is that the money from the sale will disappear into a black hole of debt, and that Baildon won't get the money we were promised for the refurbishment of our new library."

Gill Dixon, of Baildon Town Council, wanted the local authority to apply to the government's Derelict Buildings Fund to safeguard the club building and ensure the new library plan goes ahead.

"It will be a massive asset for Baildon as not just a library but a cultural centre, which is much needed," she said.

Listen to highlights from West Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.