Patient of jailed surgeon recalled to hospital before her death

Family A woman with short blonde hair smiles at the camera. The sea is behind her. she is wearing a dark-coloured blouse with a floral pattern on it.Family
Gillian Hudson died of metastatic breast cancer in 2022

An inquest has heard how a former patient of jailed breast surgeon Ian Paterson was recalled to hospital several years after he operated on her, following concerns about the type of surgery he had performed.

Gillian Hudson died of metastatic breast cancer in 2022.

She became his patient after feeling a lump in her right breast in 2003 and was referred by her GP to the breast clinic at Solihull Hospital where Paterson worked, and he later performed a mastectomy on her.

Her inquest heard on Monday that she was among patients recalled by the NHS in 2011 over concerns that some had undergone cleavage-sparing mastectomies - an unregulated surgery he carried out, which left breast tissue behind.

Doctors were unable to tell if she had undergone that procedure, however. In a statement made to the General Medical Council, Hudson had said that after her mastectomy it looked as though her breast skin had been "rolled or folded", and was not flat.

Paterson said there might have been a roll caused by inflammation, but said several doctors had not raised any concerns about residual tissue after the surgery.

Hudson was diagnosed with breast cancer again in 2016 and later developed liver and lung metasases before her death, aged 63.

Family A man with ginger hair wearing a blue hoodie stands with his arm around his mother, who has short blonde hair and wears a black shirt, red cardigan and pink and red scarf.Family
Hudson's son Dan told the inquest that her greatest joy was her family

Paterson was jailed in 2017 after being convicted of wounding patients by way of botched and unnecessary operations, and given a 20-year prison sentence.

He is due for release from prison at the halfway point of his sentence, in May next year, before the inquests into the deaths of his former patients are set to conclude.

Hudson, who was born in Gloucester, spent most of her career at King Edwards School in Edgbaston, where she taught religion and philosophy for 23 years, only leaving after being diagnosed with terminal cancer.

She said she had been blessed with "the best job in the world bar none".

Her son Dan told the inquest that her greatest joy was her family, including her husband John and her two sons.

"She was a very committed person," he said.

"She went to the gym seven days a week, which is kind of crazy. I recall on a Christmas Day she was annoyed because they weren't open.

"She was devoted to the students she taught and her family. She was also a bit of a joker, she loved to play practical jokes and that kind of thing."

The inquest heard Hudson felt a lump in her right breast in 2003 and went to see her GP.

She was referred to the breast clinic at Solihull Hospital where a doctor recorded the lump, but because he believed there was nothing suspicious, he ordered a mammogram - scheduled for her a month later, instead of being fast tracked the same day. She then became Ian Paterson's patient.

Her mammogram results suggested that her cancer was mostly a very early form of breast cancer, but Paterson said further examination found it was "considerably more aggressive or worrying than we thought".

He then performed a mastectomy on her.

Family A woman with short blonde hair grins at the camera whilst wearing a hi-viz vest which says 'Hedgehog Corner' on it.Family
"She was a very committed person," Hudson's son told the BBC

In 2011, the NHS started to recall a number of Paterson's patients over concerns that some had undergone cleavage-sparing mastectomies – an unregulated surgery he carried out which left breast tissue behind.

Hudson was among them, the inquest heard, though doctors were unable to tell if she'd had a cleavage-sparing mastectomy because of the reconstruction she had received.

In a statement made to the General Medical Council, Hudson said that after her mastectomy it looked as though her breast skin had been "rolled or folded" and "wasn't flat as I had envisioned."

Paterson said there may have been a roll caused by inflammation, but said several doctors had not raised any concerns about residual tissue after the surgery.

Press Association A side profile image of a man with short grey hair and wearing a striped shirt and dark jacket.Press Association
There are now 74 inquests open into the deaths of jailed surgeon Ian Paterson's former patients

Hudson was diagnosed with breast cancer again in 2016 and later developed liver and lung metasases.

She died at a hospice in Solihull in 2022, but Paterson said this had nothing to do with the surgery he performed, calling the idea "absolute nonsense".

Hudson's inquest will continue later this month when other medical experts will be asked to speak about her care.

There are now 74 inquests open into the deaths of Paterson's former patients.

One case, the death of 83-year-old Joan Green from Staffordshire, is being investigated by West Midlands Police after being referred by the coroner.

It is the first time the force is investigating the death of a patient of Ian Paterson.

Follow BBC Birmingham on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.