Mother's heartbreak over son's prison cell murder

West Mercia Police A mug shot of Jonathon Alcide who is wearing a grey t-shirt and has short curly black hairWest Mercia Police
Jonathan Alcide was unanimously found guilty of murder in September

The mother of a man who was killed by his cellmate at a Shropshire prison walks past her son's untouched bedroom each night before crying herself to sleep, a court has heard.

Jonathan Alcide, 36, was found guilty of murdering 49-year-old Neil Ashby at HMP Stoke Heath in July 2025 at a trial in September, and sentenced at Stafford Crown Court on Tuesday.

In a statement, Ashby's brother said his mother also walked her deceased son's dog and "imagines seeing his smiling face".

Alcide, who decided to represent himself at the sentencing hearing, accepted responsibility for Ashby's death, and was sentenced to life in prison with a minimum term of 15 years and five months.

Dean Ashby described his brother's murder as a "heinous crime", and said his brother was a kind and loving person who loved his family dearly.

"We often start crying during meal times while eating food we know Neil loved," he said.

He said his brother cared for Alcide, showing concern for his mental health and bringing him meals.

"This is the Neil we all know and love," he added.

Dean, who lives in the US, had flights booked for July 2025 to visit his brother in prison.

"My visit to the UK ended up being a funeral planning trip," he said.

"One day soon I will have to tell my children exactly what happed to their beloved Uncle Neil, before they are old enough to start Googling him themselves."

A mainly black sign with the words Stoke Heath in white letters. A hedge, at the bottom of the photo, is behind them.
The body of Neil Ashby, 49, was found at HMP Stoke Heath in Shropshire in July last year

Before the murder, Alcide was serving a two-and-a-half year sentence for causing grievous bodily harm with intent.

Paramedics were called to the prison on the morning on 1 July 2025 and found Ashby lying in his bunk, and declared him dead at the scene.

A post-mortem examination found Ashby died due to applied neck pressure, most likely as a result of a neck hold or a "broad, soft ligature".

Words were daubed on the cell wall in pen and blood, including "I did not slay them" and "they killed us… help", and the words "they killed us" were written on Ashby's back.

Alcide had denied murder, claiming he was not guilty by reason of insanity, and was instead guilty of manslaughter by diminished responsibility.

'Cruel, barbaric and depraved'

Prosecuting, Sally Howes KC said the murder had been planned, with Alcide threatening to kill his cellmate in the days before.

She said it was an "intensely close and personal form of homicide", and there had been "only one intention".

She said there was "no doubt" Alcide's mental health had deteriorated before the murder – Alcide had been suffering from depression with psychosis – but noted that the partial defence of diminished responsibility had been rejected by the jury at trial.

Representing himself, Alcide described the murder as "cruel, barbaric and depraved".

"I know that my actions have caused an unfillable void," he said.

"Neil was a good man. Kind, caring, and generous."

Passing sentence, Judge Avik Mukherjee said Ashby had tried to help Alcide with his mental health struggles while they were cellmates.

"He was bringing you food to your cell when you refused to leave, he contacted services on your behalf," he said.

"He wanted to stay sharing a cell with you because he was concerned about you.

"He had no means of escaping your violence on that fateful night."

The judge accepted Alcide had mental health issues but noted that the jury had rejected this as a defence.

"I wish to pay tribute to Neil Ashby's family and friends, and I hope that the end of this process will bring you some peace," he added.

Follow BBC Shropshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.