Giant tree to be felled after branches hit homes

BBC Two tall mature conifer trees tower above neighbouring homes and gardens beside a gravel driveway under a blue sky. BBC
Wellington residents won their fight to fell a tree that has dropped branches on their homes

Residents have won their battle to have a 140-year-old giant tree felled after it repeatedly dropped branches on nearby bungalows.

Tree owner Jonathan Rickell appealed to a government planning inspector after Telford & Wrekin Council refused permission to remove the wellingtonia, which dates back to the 1880s.

The 21m (70ft) tree is protected by a preservation order, and the council argued its removal would harm the area's appearance. Planning inspector Elaine Benson visited the site on Lindfield Drive in Wellington in October.

She agreed its removal would harm the area's appearance, but this was outweighed by the damage caused to nearby homes and the risk of more damage from falling branches.

The tree, which is also known as a giant redwood, can be seen from far away but stands just metres from bungalows. It has a history of branches falling, with damage previously reported.

During a planning consultation in May 2026, a 92-year-old resident told the council they had experienced a "very close escape when a branch fell by my front door and almost hit me".

Two tall mature conifer trees tower above neighbouring homes and gardens beside a gravel driveway under a blue sky.
The tree is said to have had a history of falling branches

In a decision announced on Thursday the inspector said there would normally be a "strong presumption against the removal of a healthy, protected tree, particularly when that tree is as prominent as the wellingtonia".

However, they noted its "long history of limb failure and reactive pruning and regrowth which includes a long-standing failure at the top of the canopy".

The inspector concluded that although removing the tree would cause "significant harm to the visual amenity of the area", felling it was justified.

They said: "It has been satisfactorily demonstrated that the risks can no longer be appropriately mitigated through arboricultural management options that comply with current best practice professional standards."

Rickell and the council must agree on a replacement tree before the wellingtonia is felled.

However, the inspector said the replacement should not be another wellingtonia, as that species would be more appropriate for planting in a public park.

Follow BBC Shropshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.