'Dramatic action' needed after NHS Grampian leaders criticised in damning report - Swinney

BBC/NHS Grampian Composite image. L-R: Laura Skaife-Knight, chief executive; Paul Bachoo, acute medical director; Dr June Brown, executive nurse director; Dr Adam Coldwells, interim chief executive; Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, executive medical director. BBC/NHS Grampian
L-R: Laura Skaife-Knight, chief executive; Paul Bachoo, former acute medical director; Dr June Brown, former executive nurse director; Dr Adam Coldwells, former interim chief executive; Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, former executive medical director

First Minister John Swinney has called for "dramatic action" to be taken after a healthcare watchdog issued a damning report into failures by senior leadership at NHS Grampian.

Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) found "major deficiencies" across the region and revealed that a failure to learn from mistakes had caused "repeated and unavoidable harm" to patients.

It also said it had lost confidence in management to deliver reliable and consistent information after Dr Gray's Hospital in Elgin continued to operate on children despite an order to halt all paediatric surgery.

NHS Grampian chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight said the board accepted the findings and apologised to patients.

Speaking at First Minister's Questions, Swinney said the report made an "appalling read" and immediate changes had been made to the senior leadership.

"It was crystal clear that the requirements to end surgery for children at Dr Gray's Hospital was not followed by NHS Grampian and that is reprehensible," the first minister told the chamber.

"It is unacceptable that arrangements that should have been stopped for proper patient safety reasons were not stopped."

Swinney said Health Secretary Angela Constance would set out a full range of actions in a statement on Tuesday.

"The report has some of the most serious issues which will have a detriment to staff and patient morale in NHS Grampian but I want the public to hear loud and clear that dramatic action has been taken," he added.

Skaife-Knight, who commissioned the review, was appointed as chief executive in June 2025 and started the role in September. Her title is mentioned in the review.

Other people who were in leadership positions at the time of the investigation include Dr Adam Coldwells, who acted as interim boss between November 2023 and September 2025; Paul Bachoo, acute medical director; Dr June Brown, executive nurse director from November 2020 until September 2026; Dr Hugh Farrow Bishop, executive medical director.

It is understood Bachoo and Bishop are no longer in the roles.

Prof John Connaghan was appointed interim chair in October.

"He is a very experienced health service leader, in whom I have the utmost confidence to lead the process of change and improvement that is required at NHS Grampian," Swinney said.

The report published on Thursday identified systemic issues and recurring weaknesses across the health board, including at Dr Gray's Hospital and Aberdeen Royal Infirmary. These included:

  • Serious weaknesses in all aspects of leadership and management of the medical workforce across NHS Grampian, including a lack of workforce plans, poor recruitment controls, and significant concerns in how doctors are managed
  • Concerns at Dr Gray's Hospital, including patient safety and the level of care given to patients, and the number of staff available to look after patients
  • A failure to fix problems on patient safety at NHS Grampian, including concerns of staff not working well together
  • A failure to deal with concerns about safety and quality of care at NHS Grampian's Board, including not ensuring services run as well as possible

What recommendations have been made?

Dr Simon Watson, medical director at HIS, described the report on NHS Grampian as "the most serious review" the healthcare watchdog has ever written.

He told BBC Scotland News the findings were "unprecedented".

Watson added it was "absolutely imperative" the health board addressed the issues "at pace" to ensure patient safety.

HIS made six recommendations:

  • Create a clear long-term plan for Dr Gray's Hospital, which states what services can be provided safely to patients and ensures there are enough staff in the hospital
  • Improve how NHS Grampian checks the quality of its services, including asking more questions when information is missing, looking at feedback from patients and staff, and showing how decisions are made
  • Create a plan for managing doctors, which includes how many are needed for each service and the skills needed for each job
  • Streamline how decisions are made and find the best method of sharing information
  • Work with other organisations, including the Scottish government, to ensure problems are resolved and the situation improves for doctors and patients
  • Implement a better structure for making decisions and explaining how decisions are made, with the chief executive and chairperson of the board leading to sort the issues in the report

Health Secretary Angela Constance called the findings "extremely serious and deeply concerning" for patients, families, local communities and staff across Grampian.

She said: "Given the seriousness of these findings, I expect the board to immediately make changes in medical leadership and to carry out any further necessary changes at a senior level to restore confidence in services.

"Patient safety must come first, and people in Moray and across NHS Grampian must have confidence in the care they receive.

"This must be a turning point for NHS Grampian and the board must act with urgency in addressing the serious concerns."

Constance added that she expected to see "demonstratable improvements" before the end of the year and she would visit Grampian on Friday for its annual review.

NHS Grampian's chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight looking at the camera, she has glasses on her head.
NHS Grampian's chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight apologised to patients

NHS Grampian's chief executive Laura Skaife-Knight initiated the review in May.

She said: "As a board we own and accept the findings, we apologise to our patients, families and communities for letting them down and we commit to putting things right."

Skaife-Knight told BBC Scotland News she had reflected on her time in the role so far but she would not resign.

"I am completely committed to NHS Grampian and leading the organisation forward," she said.

The review found serious errors in the handling of the death of a patient during surgery at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary, which the chief executive called "tragic".

"Most concerning are the unacceptable delays in investigating and implementing learning from incidents involving patient care which can prevent us from making the changes necessary to keep patients safe," Skaife-Knight said.

She added the board will consider the immediate actions that need taken and will approach the report with "openness and transparency".

NHS Grampian declared a critical incident on 26 September after emergency departments at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary and Dr Gray's Hospital struggled to cope with demand.

A small number of patients were transferred to Raigmore Hospital in Inverness from Dr Gray's Hospital and staff at NHS Tayside were on standby.

It was the first such incident declared by the board since December 2024.

The Scottish government defines the status as any localised disruption which results in a board "losing its ability to deliver critical services, or, where patients and staff may be at risk of harm".

Separate reports relating to maternity services at Aberdeen Maternity Hospital and Dr Gray's Hospital, and mental health and acute services at Dr Gray's Hospital, have also been published.

These followed inspections in April and were independent of the NHS Grampian report.

Inspectors saw evidence of long delays transferring patients from ambulances to the emergency department, with one wait as long as 14 hours.

It also criticised care in the high dependency unit at Dr Gray's Hospital, which relied on a locum consultant and lacked a medical structure to support care 24/7.

In total HIS made 50 requirements to improve safety across the different departments and hospitals.