Will e-bike scheme be a boon or a blight on Hull?

BBC A smiling man. He has shoulder-length brown hair and is wearing a black baseball cap, glasses and a black T-shirt. He is standing in a cycle shop.BBC
Jules Wood said that while e-bikes were convenient, there were dangers to users

The possibility of Hull adopting a city-wide e-bikes rental scheme has opened a debate about the pros and cons of such an initiative.

Proponents say e-bikes are clean, efficient and relatively cheap.

But detractors say there are issues over the safety of both cyclists and pedestrians, the bikes being dumped, and the infrastructure demands to make the scheme work.

The city council said it was "doing a lot of infrastructure rebuilding".

One of those to give the idea a cautious welcome is bike salesman Jules Wood, although he believes infrastructure improvements need to be made in order for the scheme to be safe for the city's cyclists.

Wood, who works at Ken Ellerker Cycles, said the scheme could be helpful for a lot of people, including students and commuters, "as long as the infrastructure and the safety nets are there".

He said it could help people take on shift work at times when public transport might not be available.

But he has concerns about some of the hazards, including poor-quality cycling lanes, potholes, inconsiderate drivers, roadworks and even the weather.

"If the infrastructure is better, it is a lot safer and people can focus on what's ahead of them rather than constantly looking down and looking everywhere," Wood added.

A man with grey hair and a beard. He is wearing a smart suit with a white ribbon pinned on. He is standing in a civic building's tiled hall.
Paul Drake-Davis thinks an e-bike rental scheme could have a positive impact on the city's economy

For Hull City Council cabinet member Paul Drake-Davis, the focus is on the economic benefits the scheme might bring.

He said the local authority was "doing a lot of infrastructure rebuilding", including a cycle path on Freetown Way, and he added the council also had a local cycling and walking implementation plan in development.

Drake-Davis said he hoped the scheme would provide "marginal gains" to the city's economy, by helping out-of-work people secure job opportunities, and the council could introduce cheaper tariffs for unemployed people.

Hull follows smaller cities sich as Canterbury and Aberdeen, which have recently welcomed new schemes after larger cities such as London and Paris introduced then many years ago.

"There are a lot of towns across the country, [around] the world, that are smaller than Hull that are benefiting from this," Drake-Davis said.

Elsewhere, residents have told of their frustration about the abandoning of e-bikes.

In Falmouth, Cornwall, people have been throwing e-bikes into the sea.

And in Nottingham, some of them have been dumped miles from the city centre.

The bikes there are not supposed to be used outside a designated area, with people who fail to follow the rules liable to be fined.

But there have been complaints about vandalised machines being left lying around with wires exposed and pedestrians having to step into the road to avoid them.

Drake-Davis said that was "not something we're going to allow to happen" in Hull, and deterrents would be put in place.

He also said the bikes would have mandatory working front and back lights.

A well as helping job-seekers, Drake-Davis said the scheme could have a positive economic impact on other areas of the city, pointing to recent research that suggested converting parking bays into places for parking bikes could boost nearby trade.

"So these things help bring more economic activity to areas where maybe they're suffering a little bit more at the moment," he said.

A row of e-bikes parked at a cycle bay in a city centre.
People are already using e-bikes to commute into the city centre

In Leeds, where a scheme run by Beryl has been operating since 2023, there were mixed views on its success and whether it should be introduced in Hull.

Charlotte Hopkins, 19, was positive, saying e-bike users can "get everywhere a lot easier and quicker, and cheaper as well".

Malcolm Clifford, who uses the bikes two or three times a week, called the Leeds scheme "fantastic".

But he said that while "every city should have it as far as I'm concerned", he had some advice for those hoping to implement the scheme in Hull.

"I think there are things you need to be careful of. Leeds has got quite a lot of infrastructure with the cycle lanes," he said.

"You do need to be a bit careful with scooters and bikes on pedestrian areas... But I think if you do get that side of it right, it's a fantastic scheme."

However, Philip Alcock, 39, had reservations, about the scheme – mainly due to dumped bikes.

"It can look really untidy and it really does obstruct you if you're trying to walk at a busy time as well, and there are other people trying to go around it," he said.

Download the BBC News app from the App Store for iPhone and iPad or Google Play for Android devices