From twig-like to wonky: the Christmas trees that sparked controversy

John Devine/BBC A Christmas tree in the middle of a town square slightly leaning to the left. John Devine/BBC
Residents in March, Cambridgeshire, actually requested a tree like this after the town's previous one proved such a hit

Whether it is on the wonk or just a little bit underwhelming, it would not be the festive season without a town centre's Christmas tree causing a little bit of controversy.

This year's opinion-splitting centrepiece comes courtesy of Ipswich, in Suffolk, after the shape of it was likened to a "giant sex toy", especially at night when it is lit up.

Towering over shoppers on The Cornhill, it is the town's "most talked about tree in years", according to Ipswich Central boss, Lee Walker.

This is not the first Christmas tree to divide opinion and it will not be the last. But what other trees across the region have sparked debate over the years?

Cambridgeshire's 'leaning Tower of Pisa'

John Devine/BBC A Christmas tree on the wonk in the middle of a town.John Devine/BBC
The tree, located on Market Place, in March, is credited with putting the town on the map

This tilting tree in March, Cambridgeshire, was initially met with much annoyance from residents, many of whom likened it to the leaning tower of Pisa.

However, it actually went on to become a global sensation.

So much so, councillors were inundated with requests asking for a similarly quirky "banana" shaped tree to be put up the next year – which they came good on.

Essex's 'twig'

Supplied A collage images of two images side by side. On the left is an image of a twig-like and thin Christmas tree in the centre of a town. On the right is an image of a much fuller tree which has been decorated with lights.Supplied
Outrage saw Clacton swap out its scrawny Christmas tree for a new one just a week after putting it up

Clacton-on-Sea's 15ft (5m) tree in 2013 was considered to be so bad by critics that it was quickly replaced with a different specimen twice the size.

Located in the Town Square, it had been described as being a "twig", with Tendring District Council even saying it was "not man enough for the job".

Ian Wickes, of the Federation of Small Businesses, which had gifted the original tree, said the organisation had been "needled appropriately" about its tree.

Peterborough's 'Ferrero Rocher'

Emma Gordon A black and white image of a large white Christmas tree made out of balls. In front of it silhouettes of a man and a woman can be seen. The man is on one knee proposing. Emma Gordon
Peterborough's famous Ferrero Rocher Christmas tree

Not all of the region's most-talked about Christmas trees get tongues wagging for the wrong reasons.

This stunner from 2016 in Peterborough provided the backdrop to a proposal, which was captured – initially unknowingly - by a photographer.

Emma Gordon had taken several photos before later noticing they showed two strangers' romantic moment.

A truly magical moment… but it still didn't stop residents branding the £40,000 tree a "waste of money" and "plastic and pretentious".

It was also compared to a plate of Ferrero Rocher chocolates by a councillor in the area.

Norfolk's 'alternative trees'

RockShopBistro/Cromer Museum A collage images of two picture side by side. On the left is a picture of a load of sausage rolls stacked in the shape of a tree. On the right is a picture showing a thin mistle-toe inspired tree. RockShopBistro/Cromer Museum
For better or worse, Cromer has gained a reputation for putting up alternative Christmas trees

Cromer has had its fair share of quirky Christmas trees in recent years, which rendered it nigh on impossible to single out just the one.

So, with that in mind, I give you the coastal town's giant mistletoe-inspired tree, traffic cone tree in the Cottage pub, and huge three-dimensional advent calendar tree.

There was also the Rock Shop Bistro's edible – and therefore short-lived - Christmas tree made out of a stack of freshly made sausage rolls.

Make of those what you will.

Jewson Two men standing either side of a large metal or plastic looking green tree-shaped structure with advent calendar like doors on it.Jewson
This advent calendar-inspired tree was put up in Cromer in 2014

Suffolk's 'bauble tree'

The silver Christmas tree which is made up of several large baubles is pictured lying on its side on the ground after it fell over in strong winds. Concrete blocks that had been holding it up have also fallen over. Other debris can be seen scattered around the tree in the night time image.
The bauble tree in Ipswich met somewhat of an undignified end when it was blown over

As we already know, one of Suffolk's efforts this Christmas has come in for some criticism, for apparently looking like a sex toy, no less.

But this is not the first time the county (will it ever learn?) has missed the mark in the eyes of festive shoppers.

In 2023, the tree outside The Drabbet Smock on Peas Hill in Haverhill became a "fun talking-point" after it started to lean "a little too far".

Cue the town council, which brought in heavy plant machinery to "de-wonk" the seasonal attraction and straighten it, once more, to a "respectable angle".

Made of 41 aluminium spheres, Ipswich's infamous metal bauble Christmas tree also proved quite controversial when revealed in 2012.

It was later moved to the waterfront in 2017 before being blown into the side of the University of Suffolk during Storm Henk in 2024 and damaged beyond repair.

Supplied A large Christmas tree covered in colourful lights lit up on a dark night.Supplied
The supposedly "giant sex toy" Christmas tree in Ipswich that started all this off

Bedfordshire's lack of tree

Tony Fisher/BBC A man wearing a green T-shirt standing in front of a Christmas tree in a foyer area of a block of flats.Tony Fisher/BBC
Michael Haywood said a tree had been allowed for the duration of his time at the block of flats

Back in 2023 in Bedford, it was not so much the quality or designs of Christmas trees that were the issue – it was more that some residents were not allowed to have one.

People living in the Boswell Court flats told the BBC they were not permitted to have a plastic tree in their foyer unless a caretaker was present due to fire safety reasons.

Michael Haywood, 79 at the time, said: "It's bah-humbug, it's going to spoil Christmas."

Northamptonshire's 'tree for Number Ten'

Harry Stevens/BBC A couple stand in front of a field of Christmas trees. The taller man is wearing a green jumper and a blue gilet, the smaller woman has blonde hair and wears a blue jumper and beige pinafore. Harry Stevens/BBC
Ella Miles said her husband's dream was to one day supply the towering tree which takes pride of place outside No.10 Downing Street

Judging by the difficulty I had trying to find anything about dodgy or disliked trees in Northamptonshire, I'm assuming the county's track record must be pretty good.

Its Welford Christmas Tree Farm has even been chosen to supply No.10 Downing Street with two of its 12ft (3.6m) Nordmann fir trees this festive season.

They will be displayed in the entrance hall and pillared room of one of the country's most famous properties, currently home, of course, to Prime Minister Andy Burnham.

Will and Ella Miles, who own the farm, said: "So many people say their Christmas doesn't begin until they've had a visit to the farm. It's a real honour."

Do you have a story suggestion? Contact us below.