Kilmarnock

We asked for your thoughts on Neil McCann being appointed as Kilmarnock's new manager.

Here's what some of you said:

Adam: Was hoping for Robbie Neilson. I am willing to give McCann a chance but can he walk the walk? Seems a bit desperate from Killie, but clearly our budget is like our balloons, our belief and our ambition: deflated and shrinking by the day.

Robin: I have absolutely no confidence that this will work with McCann and Billy Dodds but I pray I'm wrong. They don't have a proven track record and what we need in our current position is someone that can go in and shake things up. We desperately need attacking additions to the squad and I am very sceptical they can attract these kinds of players. Championship seems inevitable.

Garry: Potentially an excellent appointment. Well done to Billy Bowie and board. Let's all get behind him and move forward.

William: This appointment says more about our financial position than anything else. Neilson was the standout candidate but we went for the cheap option.

Alan: When something doesn't feel right it normally isn't. Mistakes were made appointing Stuart Kettlewell, and it looks very similar now. When the fanbase doesn't want you it almost always ends badly. Hope I'm wrong.

Robert: He can't be any worse than what we had. He needs to make positive signings in this window and his goal must be at least 10th. As a fan I'll be right behind him.

David: A horrendous appointment. The board preparing us for relegation. To go from European football and Derek McInnes to this in a short period of time is quite something.

Matt: Good choice but a hard gig to turn the season around.

Brett: Really happy with the appointment of McCann and Dodds - both know the Scottish Premiership very well and Neil is a really serious tactician. Realistically we would have struggled to get a better duo with any less risk.

Image source, Jeff Holmes

Neil McCann could have continued his "stress-free" life by contributing punditry and analysis on Kilmarnock's crucial relegation showdown with Livingston this weekend.

Instead, he will be in the away dugout for a baptism of fire as Killie boss.

McCann, alongside assistant Billy Dodds, is tasked with keeping the second-bottom Rugby Park club in the Premiership after succeeding Stuart Kettlewell.

The 51-year-old had a spell on the Rangers coaching staff for a few months last season but this is his first full-time managerial position since 2018 at Dundee.

And former Premiership midfielder Ryan Flynn is impressed by McCann's desire to plunge back into management.

"What we can say is Neil McCann must have a real hunger and desire to go into that job," Flynn told the BBC's Scottish Football Podcast.

"I feel that he must have got that appetite from going back into coaching at Rangers. Something's definitely changed.

"He could be stress free, sitting in the studio talking about football but he wants to walk the walk, which is great, and I think he'll definitely bring that to the players. Just his enthusiasm towards the game, him and Billy Dodds.

"They know it's a difficult situation, the league table doesn't lie, it's going to be tough.

"But then the flip of that is they're probably guaranteed to at least finish second bottom. They'll go in there, try and get that belief back and try and chase those teams in front."

Kilmarnock are currently four points above Saturday's hosts Livingston having played a game more.

"There's no better first game than Livingston away. They're straight in at the deep end," Flynn added.

"Basics first and then after that can you get the victories and the points on the board."

Image source, SNS

Saturday's trip to Livingston throws Kilmarnock's new management team "straight into the deep end", says the club's assistant coach Billy Dodds.

The Rugby Park side announced Neil McCann as their replacement for Stuart Kettlewell on Tuesday.

McCann will be assisted by former team-mate Dodds and the pair, who worked together at Rangers last term, face a crucial match at the weekend.

Kilmarnock are currently 11th in the Scottish Premiership and have not won in 14 games, but they could end that wretched run with victory at bottom side Livingston.

"Straight in at the deep end and we're under no illusions what's required," Dodds said on BBC Sportsound.

"But we have a good squad of players, maybe a little tweak here and there, and we'll get on with it. It'll be tough, but it's a role we're very much looking forward to."

On the recruitment process, Dodds added: "It was all pretty quickly organised. Yesterday talks started then it was all done by this morning."

Former Kilmarnock goalkeeper Cammy Bell has backed "shrewd appointment" Neil McCann to steer the club to Premiership survival this season.

McCann, 51, and assistant Billy Dodds most recently served as interim assistants at Rangers last season under Barry Ferguson.

McCann's only previous permanent job as manager was an 18-month stint at Dundee that ended in October 2018 with the club bottom of the top flight.

Having worked mainly as a pundit since then, the former Scotland winger now takes over a team that are winless in 14 games and second bottom of the table.

"I think it's a good appointment by Kilmarnock," Bell told BBC Scotland.

"When I look at where Kilmarnock are, it's between them and Livingston [to get relegated], they're starting to get a little bit isolated.

"They've only won two games all season. When you're looking for a manager in the situation that they're in, you're looking for a manager with Scottish football experience. Neil McCann and Billy Dodds have that in abundance.

"So I think it's a really shrewd appointment from the club to where they are at this moment in time.

"The job for Neil and Billy will be to go in there and keep Kilmarnock in the league this season. Because they've been in such poor form they'll need to turn it around quickly and they've got a huge match against Livingston at the weekend.

"I see the passion within them as people so I think they'll bring that to the team.

"It's a big month for the two guys. I think they'll be successful, I think they will turn this around and hopefully see Kilmarnock safe in the top flight again."

Sandy Armour
Fan writer

Neil McCann has just been announced as the new manager and, much like Stuart Kettlewell, he was not the fans' choice.

However, every new manager deserves a chance and the Killie support will give him that although our patience is wearing thin.

Several new faces are required if we want to stay up and decent quality is needed rather than some journeymen.

Good luck to the new management team and a win at Livingston on Saturday would be the perfect tonic although it is never easy there.

Kris Doolan's interim reign ended without a victory and we once again looked like relegation fodder last weekend as Hibs briefly got out of second gear to brush us aside.

There was a 15-minute spell in the second half when it looked like we might get something from the game but our lack of quality and rock-bottom confidence is there for all to see.

I've been a Killie fan since JFK was shot so it's a sad day when The Traitors ends up being your Saturday highlight.

Every game is massive when you are in 11th place but the trip to Livingston is your archetypal six-pointer.

Sandy Armour is editor of The Killie Hippo fanzine

Image source, SNS

The Kilmarnock board have "complete faith" in Neil McCann and Billy Dodds' ability to drive the club forward.

McCann - who had not been a full-time manager in more than seven years - is Killie's new boss on a contract until summer 2028, with Dodds joining him as assistant.

The Rugby Park club have gone 14 matches without victory and occupy the relegation play-off spot in the Premiership.

Announcing the new manager, the board said in a statement: "We fully understand how important it was to get this appointment right.

"After a thorough process, we are assured that Neil and Billy have the qualities, experience, and character required to lead Kilmarnock Football Club forward.

"We have complete faith in their ability to do what needs to be done to keep this club competing in the Scottish Premiership. Both Neil and Billy know the Scottish league inside out, understand its demands, and share a vision that aligns strongly with the culture and values of this football club.

"This is a significant appointment for Kilmarnock FC. We are confident the players will adapt quickly to their leadership and respond positively to the clarity, belief, and ambition they bring at a crucial moment for the club."

Kilmarnock have turned to Neil McCann to keep the club in the Scottish Premiership.

The former Dundee boss and his assistant Billy Dodds have signed two-and-a-half year contracts at Rugby Park.

McCann succeeds Stuart Kettlewell, who was sacked last month after winning just two of his 17 league games in charge.

Is McCann the right choice for the job? Can he steer the club, currently second bottom, away from the drop?

Let us know your thoughts here.

Image source, PA Media

Robbie Neilson will hold further talks with Kilmarnock on Monday regarding the vacant managerial position at Rugby Park. (Ewan Paton on X), external

Read the rest of Monday's Scottish gossip.

Watch highlights as Hibernian dispatch struggling Kilmarnock in the Scottish Premiership.

Available in UK only

We sought your views after Kilmarnock's 3-1 home defeat by Hibernian. Here are a selection of Killie fans' thoughts...

Frank: Let's hope there will be a big clearance of the deadwood currently in this squad when new manager takes over. The current squad have no fight, no determination and unfortunately no skill. We still have e chance to redeem part of the season with a new manager and players who have some heart and skill. We can only hope.

James: Every week it's getting worse. The new manager has to hit the ground running starting next week. The quality is just not there and we must start picking up points to have a fighting chance otherwise its Championship football next season.

Robert: Calling themselves players is a joke, new manager has only one goal - 10th.

Adam: Too slow getting into the game! We are the home team but everyone seems more comfortable on the ball than we do! We need to get in their faces from the get go! We need a new backbone to the team, especially a playmaker in midfield.

David: We are so lacking in confidence and with no direction. It's not KD to blame as he has inherited a squad with low esteem. Forwards need to take a chance that the ball will fall for them by making runs into space. The defence, well where do I start? At least five players need to be shifted out this month and replaced by more technically gifted midfielders and forwards who can move their feet quickly and pass accurately.

Stephen: That was as tame a first half as I've seen from any Kilmarnock side. It looked like a training exercise for Hibs. We at least showed a bit of spirit for a spell in the second half, but if you recruit Championship level players, you get Championship level quality. Fourteen without a win would suggest you don't belong in the league. It is embarrassing and already it looks like we're pinning our hopes on the play-off, a situation no Killie fan would be confident of us winning.

Two goals from Elie Youan and a Jamie McGrath penalty ensured Hibernian made it three Scottish Premiership wins in a row with victory over a Kilmarnock side whose winless run in the league was stretched to 14 games.

Read the match report

Have your say

Image source, SNS

Kilmarnock interim manager Kris Doolan: "We showed character, first of all, to get back into the game. When you get back to 1-1, we were well on top.

"It's so tight, there's small margins between the teams and Hibs are a top side. Top side with a top manager. Losing David Watson [to a red card] doesn't help us.

"The difference between the first half and the second half was sheer intensity and willingness to run and press and get after people.

"A new manager will come in and make their own mind up. Any manager that comes in is taking on good people. Everybody's trying.

"The positivity a fresh manager will bring could be enough just to turn the corner. The players are definitely not far away, they just need that wee nudge along."

Former Dundee manager Neil McCann is being considered for the vacancy at Kilmarnock along with Aberdeen coach Peter Leven and former Dundee United and Heart of Midlothian boss Robbie Neilson. (Scottish Sun), external

Read Saturday's Scottish Gossip in full.

Image source, SNS

Image source, SNS

Kilmarnock will assess Tom Lowery, who went off with a tight thigh at Dundee on Tuesday.

They hope to have Scott Tiffoney back and new defender Michael Schjonning-Larsen could feature.

Max Stryjek (heart), Kyle Magennis (knee), Jamie Brandon (ankle/groin), Djenairo Daniels (knee) and Matty Kennedy (hip) remain out.

Hibernian could welcome back Jordan Obita and Migual Chaiwa from international duty but Rocky Bushiri is still away at the Africa Cup of Nations.

Kieron Bowie is likely to return after illness but Martin Boyle (hamstring) and Nicky Cadden (calf) are set to miss out.

Image source, SNS

• Kilmarnock have won just one of their past 15 Scottish Premiership meetings with Hibernian (D6 L8), and are winless in their past eight (D5 L3) since a 1-0 triumph in November 2022.

• Hibernian have drawn each of their past four away league visits to Kilmarnock, despite scoring the opening goal in three of those four trips.

• Having beaten St Mirren 2-0 in their first league game of 2025, Kilmarnock could start two successive years with a league win for the first time since doing so in 2014 and 2015 (both wins over St Mirren).

• Hibernian haven't won their first league game in any of the past five calendar years (D2 L3) since a 2-1 victory over Hamilton Academical in 2020.

• Kilmarnock are winless in their past 13 league games (D3 L10), their longest run in the top flight since a run of 14 between September 1999 and February 2000.

Image source, SNS

Kilmarnock forward Tyreece John-Jules has agreed a new contract to remain at Rugby Park for the rest of the season.

The 24-year-old had joined on a short-term deal in October.

He has scored twice in 11 Killie appearances.

The Rugby Park side are second bottom of the Scottish Premiership and host Hibernian on Saturday.

Kilmarnock are "close to completing" their search for Stuart Kettlewell's successor and expect to appoint a new manager next week.

Kettlewell was sacked earlier this month following a 10-match winless run, which has extended to 13 games under interim boss Kris Doolan.

Killie remain second bottom of the Premiership.

A statement from the club's board said: "We know it has been a frustrating and unsettled time with results clearly not what we would have wanted this season.

"We also know that fans are looking for clarity on next steps, which is totally understandable.

"The club has been carefully working through the process of replacing Stuart Kettlewell and we are close to completing that process. We expect to have a new first-team manager in place next week.

"This is an important decision for the future of Kilmarnock FC. We are determined to get it right and appoint someone who understands the club and what it means to supporters and most importantly, someone who can hit the ground running and deliver much-needed results on the park."

We asked for your thoughts after second-bottom Kilmarnock's winless run continued with a 2-1 defeat at Dundee.

Here's a taste of what you had to say:

James: Enough is enough. We have no forwards who can score goals, we have two defenders who are the worst in Scottish football, a powder-puff midfield and a goalie who is probably the best player in the team, and he is poor at best. We are doomed and we won't come back up for a while.

Kenny: Kris Doolan isn't even close to being the right man for Killie in any position. No fight, no passion and no heart, this team would struggle in the Championship and that's exactly where Killie are going. We need a leaders on that park and in the dugout to fight for our team!

Graeme: Outplayed from start to finish. We need a managerial appointment ASAP, someone who can take stock of situation and use the players they have in an effective system. Not going to be a good season but with the right appointment it doesn't have to be a disaster.

Robert: Players are simply not good enough, the signings of Stuart Kettlewell were poor with maybe one or two that were okay. However, the mental weakness is something that needs to be addressed as they cross the white line - we need the right manager and a set of signings, most likely loans, in January.

Craig: Maybe besides the first Falkirk game I thought that was our worst performance of the season. Dundee were lucky not to be a few ahead of us as they battered us. Now in a race against Livingston to avoid the drop and we need more quality players and more importantly a strong manager who can actually get a reaction. Strong January required.

Bill: It's becoming more and more obvious to me, Kilmarnock have players more of Championship standard yet we ask them to try to be Premiership standard - it's asking the impossible. I doubt any managerial appointment could change the situation. Future plans must start from this point.

Watch highlights as Dundee make it back-to-back Scottish Premiership wins for the first time this season with a 2-1 victory over Kilmarnock. (Available to UK users only)

Dundee took a significant step towards Scottish Premiership safety as they came from behind against Kilmarnock and doomed their visitors to a 13th game without victory.

Read the full match report.

Have your say here.