Summary

  • Spain's Civil Guard tell the BBC their priority is to continue to identify victims of yesterday's train crash, which killed 69 people - key details to know

  • Police have appealed to families of the passengers to provide DNA samples to help them

  • Former minister Fátima Báñez was among those killed in the crash, Spain's employment ministry confirms

  • Some people have taken to social media to ask for information to help find their loved ones: they're posting details of which train they were on, desperate for any news, writes the BBC's Sarah Rainsford

  • Last night, protesters gathered outside the Spanish transport ministry demanding accountability over the crash

  • The disaster occurred when a train travelling from Madrid to Seville barrelled into a stationary train on Wednesday morning

  • Audio recordings appear to show that one high-speed train was given clearance to move even though another had stalled some 25km (15 miles) up ahead

Are you in the area?

  1. Relatives desperately await news as rescuers comb wreckagepublished at 10:40 GMT

    Rajini Vaidyanathan
    Reporting from the crash site

    As dawn broke here at the crash site, police drones and helicopters hovered above.

    The two trains are still on the tracks, as the sun came up. Through the night emergency workers were here, continuing their efforts to pick through the wreckage.

    They're trying to find DNA and other evidence which might help identify more of the victims on board. A police van with around a dozen sniffer dogs also drove past us.

    Nearby in the town of Urda relatives are desperately waiting for news.

  2. How Spain's deadly train disaster unfoldedpublished at 10:16 GMT

    The damaged derailed carriages of a train that has fallen off its tracksImage source, AFP via Getty Images

    There are still many question marks over this train crash disaster - one of the worst in Europe's modern history - but this is what we know so far about what has happened.

    There were more than 500 passengers travelling across the two trains. One, the Iryo 6076, left Madrid at 07:54 local time (06:54 GMT) carrying 147 passengers to Seville.

    The other, Renfe's AVE 2080, was also heading to Seville. It departed Madrid at 08:00 local time with 397 passengers on board.

    Just before 09:00 local time, the AVE train crashed into the rear of the Iryo train, which appears to have been stationary near Urda in Toledo. At least three carriages of the Iryo train fell down an embankment off the tracks, as did part of the AVE train.

    According to Spain's Transport Minister Óscar Puente, a computer failure led to the initial halting of six trains - including the two which crashed.

    Puente said that in the event of system failures "the control centre takes over", and that a decision apparently to allow trains to move again was made "under inexplicable circumstances".

    Aerial images showing the positions of two high-speed trains involved in a collision near Toledo, Spain. The image show an Iryo train which had been travelling from Madrid to Seville and the Renfe AVE 2080 train which had been travelling in same direction behind it, with arrows indicating direction of travel right to left. An inset photo shows several derailed and overturned carriages from the Iryo train. Another label points to part of the Renfe train on the opposite side
  3. 'There are still people to be accounted for,' says government representativepublished at 10:06 GMT

    Emergency workers stand on a rail line in front of a train that is on its side. The carriages of a second train that have been thrown off the line can be seen behind itImage source, Getty Images

    A representative from the Spanish government has called for "accountability" following the rail disaster.

    Domènec Ruiz Devesa tells the BBC's Today programme a little earlier this morning that the crash is "not necessarily connected to a general lack of investment" in the Spanish rail network.

    Devesa says the crash is "very different" to another incident on the same train line earlier this year which killed more than 40 people.

    He says the main hypothesis for the more recent crash is "first the failure of the electronic system and then a human mistake".

    He adds that there needs to be a technical and policy review following the disaster.

    Devesa says that first step is to care for the victims, the wounded and continue the emergency efforts.

    "Even as we speak not all bodies have been recovered," he adds. "There are people who are still to be accounted for."

  4. Local president calls for blood donationspublished at 09:56 GMT

    President of Castilla-La Mancha, Emiliano Garcia-Page (left), Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez stands behind himImage source, Europa Press via Getty Images
    Image caption,

    President of Castilla-La Mancha, Emiliano Garcia-Page (left), Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez stands behind him

    The president of Spain's Castilla-La Mancha region, Emiliano García-Page, has been speaking at a news conference alongside Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez.

    He tells reporters that has been some positive news about some of the survivors in hospital.

    He gives his sincere thanks to all the staff who have been involved and asks people in the coming days to give blood.

    He adds that his thoughts are with the victims and "we [must] never forget we are confronted by a human tragedy".

  5. Spanish PM praises 'tremendous' effort of rescuerspublished at 09:49 GMT

    Pedro Sanchez speaks into a microhphone flanked by officialsImage source, Europa Press via Getty Images

    Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has said that assistance centres have been established in the immediate region following the train disaster.

    He tells a news conference that psychological assistance is being provided for relatives of victims, the victims themselves and for anyone who was in the area of the accident yesterday.

    Sánchez praises the "tremendous work" done by rescuers and says the Spanish government is working very hard to find out the causes of the incident.

  6. Spain's civil guard tells BBC priority is to identify victimspublished at 09:45 GMT

    Rajini Vaidyanathan and Paloma Prieto Del Valle
    BBC News

    Speaking to BBC News in the last few moments, a spokesperson from the Guardia Civil says they have deployed more then 900 people from different specialist departments.

    The priority now is the process of identification. They don't know how long that is going to take.

    The Guardia Civil urges those with missing family members to go to one of the local centres which have been set up to offer DNA samples to help with victim identification.

    Asked if the death toll could rise, the spokesperson says they do not know yet whether that is likely and their main goal remains to identify the victims.

  7. Train driver told to 'resume journey' at normal speed by control centrepublished at 09:37 GMT

    Wreckage of one train is seen in the early morning sun. It is crumped and carriages are displaced. rescue workers can beImage source, Reuters

    Audio recordings published by Spanish news outlets, including El Pais and RTVE, reveal the conversations that took place between the two train's drivers and the control centre in the Spanish capital ahead of the crash.

    In one recording, a control centre operator tells the Renfe driver to resume its journey at normal speed after some technical issues.

    "Continue your journey and then proceed under [Lateral Signalling Block], at normal speed with normal operation," the control centre operator says to the driver.

    The driver replies, "At normal speed?" To which the controller says: "Yes."

    The Lateral Signaling Block is a back-up or alternative train system used when the automatic signalling or data transmission system fails.

    Later, the driver of the other Iryo train says in another audio recording that communication with the train-control system has been lost and they are stationary at Urda.

    The train "is stationary in front of the entry signal at Urda", the driver tells the control centre operator. After a series of exchanges, the driver is then told to "resume the journey" normally.

    The Iryo driver then contacts the control centre again, according to a later recording, saying they cannot start the train. "The train won't allow me to control the [security] system. That's why I am still stopped in front of the entry signal," they say.

    The latter recording suggests that the controller had been notified that the Iryo train remained stationary as the Renfe train approached.

  8. Audio recordings show train given clearance to proceed, despite stall aheadpublished at 09:30 GMT

    The two trains on the tracks, one has derailed from the tracks down the embankmentImage source, EPA/Shutterstock

    There's been a lot of focus on a control centre which Spain's Transport Minister Óscar Puente says typically takes charge of deciding when trains can move again in the event of system failures.

    Spanish media has obtained audio recordings obtained between train controllers working for a rail infrastructure company in Adif in Madrid and the train drivers.

    They appear to show that one high-speed train was given clearance to move at 08:36 even though another some 25km ahead had stalled.

    One train, run by state-owned operator Renfe, had 397 passengers on board. Ahead of it on the same line was a train run by private operator Iryo, with 147 passengers.

    A reported issue with the automatic signalling system - a computer failure - had forced all trains to halt on the affected stretch.

    But later the Renfe train was ordered to proceed in "error", according to Spain's transport minister.

    In our next post, we'll bring you details about what was said in the exchange.

  9. PM says 'whole of Spain grieving' as audio reveals exchanges before deadly crashpublished at 09:27 GMT

    Emergency workers search a disaster site in front of a the wreckage of a train. A second train can be seen on its side. A crane is nearby.Image source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Emergency workers searched the disaster site for survivors under powerful floodlights overnight

    Audio recordings published in Spanish media reveal the conversations between train drivers and a railway control centre minutes before one of the worst rail disasters in Europe's modern history.

    In one recording a control centre operator tells a train driver to "continue your journey... at normal speed with normal operation" following some technical issues.

    The recordings come as Spain has entered three days of mourning. At least 68 people were killed and dozens more were injured when a train travelling from Madrid to Seville crashed into a second train that appears to have been stationary on Wednesday morning.

    Emergency crews worked through the night to cut open metal carriages in the search for victims, with many of the crash victims still to be identified.

    Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez has described how the "whole of Spain is grieving" following the disaster.

    Hundreds of personnel have been deployed to the disaster site to help with recovery efforts, according to Spain's interior ministry, with drones and helicopters being used to find victims and remove rubble.

  10. Workers confront horror of crash site as Spaniards begin asking tough questionspublished at 21:46 GMT 28 October

    Sarah Rainsford
    Eastern and Southern Europe correspondent, reporting from the crash site

    A nighttime scene showing a lit up field with cranes over the train carriages

    More than 12 hours after the two trains collided here near Urda, and well after nightfall, the massive recovery operation is still in full swing.

    There are powerful lights at the scene, illuminating several train carriages tilting dangerously to one side on the tracks.

    I can make out some of the wreckage of other carriages, cascading down the embankment. Among it all are the emergency workers, confronting the horror of Europe’s worst rail disaster in many years.

    The occasional drone takes off to survey the scene, shining bright beams down below, and there’s the non-stop clunk and thud of metal as giant cranes and cutters go to work in the ruins, perhaps checking for more victims.

    At one point a funeral van passed us on the road.

    As families with missing relatives wait, and forensic teams in Toledo work to identify dozens of people who were killed here, Spaniards all over the country are asking tough questions about how this disaster was possible.

    We're ending our live coverage here, but you can read more in the news story.

  11. Grief and anger in Spain after train collision kills at least 68published at 21:29 GMT 28 October

    Rescue personnel work at the site of the collision. It is dark and the scene is lit by floodlights.Image source, Reuters

    At least 68 people have been killed and dozens more injured in Spain after a high-speed train collided with another train just south of the capital Madrid.

    More than 500 passengers were travelling on the two trains at the time - this graphic shows how the crash unfolded.

    "Suitcases started flying, people started screaming," a survivor tells the BBC, saying they don't think they will ever recover from witnessing the horrific aftermath.

    Transport Minister Óscar Puente says a computer failure led to the initial halting of six trains, including the two trains that subsequently collided.

    "In the event of a system failure, the control centre takes over," Puente says, adding it was the control centre which decided to allow the trains to move again, without any speed restrictions.

    That decision, he says, was made "under inexplicable circumstances".

    Protesters have gathered outside the transport ministry, and one of the country's largest trade unions has called on Puente to resign.

    Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez says "the whole of Spain is grieving", adding: "We will get to the bottom of this, and if there has been any negligence, it will come to light."

  12. Spain crash among the worst rail disasters in Europe in modern historypublished at 20:22 GMT 28 October

    An archive picture from 2013 shows the aftermath of a train crash near Santiago de Compostela, in northwestern Spain. Two train carriages are positioned at a right angle to each other, having been derailed from the train track, while surrounded in debrisImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    A train derailed in north-western Spain in 2013, killing 80 people

    Today's incident, which has killed at least 68 people, is the second deadly train collision on the same line in less than a year and will likely raise questions over Spain's train infrastructure.

    It is among the most deadly train, tram and subway crashes in Europe in recent years:

    Greece, 2023: A passenger train from Athens to Thessaloniki smashed head-on into a goods train on the same line in northern Greece, killing 57 people.

    Spain, 2013: A railway accident left 80 people dead and 145 injured when an eight-carriage high-speed train derailed and crashed near the north-western city of Santiago de Compostela.

    Montenegro, 2006: At least 44 were killed and more than 180 injured when a passenger train plunged into a ravine outside the capital, Podgorica.

    Austria, 2000: A cable car on a funicular train caught fire in a mountain tunnel high above the town of Kaprun, killing 155 people.

    Germany, 1998: A high-speed train derailed in Eschede in Lower Saxony, killing 101 people, in what was the country's deadliest post-war rail disaster.

  13. Minute's silence held in honour of crash victimspublished at 20:12 GMT 28 October

    People in the regional centre of Toledo held a minute's silence at 20:00 local time (19:00 GMT) for the victims of today's train crash.

    Local leader Emiliano García-Page and Education Minister Milagros Tolon were among those taking part in the vigil.

    People gather in a large crowd to take part in a minute’s silence in memory of the victims of the train accident in Toledo. The group is standing outside Toledo Town Hall, which is an old historical looking building which is illuminated by yellow lightImage source, Europa Press via Getty Images
  14. 'Suitcases started flying, people started screaming': Survivor recalls moment of collisionpublished at 20:04 GMT 28 October

    Sergi Forcada Freixas
    Reporting from Urda

    A young man stands in the middle of a quiet street, dimly lit by a nearby street lamp, while talking into a microphone. He has short black hair, which is swept across his forehead, and is wearing a black hoodie

    Tangui Binier, 22, is among the survivors of today's crash.

    Recalling the moment the two trains collided, he says the impact was "very sudden" and "happened so fast”.

    “Suitcases started flying, people started screaming. We were lucky because our wagon actually went forward and it stopped but the wagons behind flipped over," he tells the BBC.

    Binier says he was among the first people to get out of the train, when he saw it had been "completely flipped over" and there was another train behind it.

    “There were people in danger, it was really hard to see," he says.

    "There were dead bodies, there were missing limbs. I don’t know if that is something I will ever recover from."

  15. Train disaster could influence Spanish election campaignpublished at 19:59 GMT 28 October

    Sergi Forcada Freixas
    Reporting from Urda

    Spain's Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez speaks at the crash site with a serious expression on his face.Image source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Spanish Prime Minister Pedro Sanchez speaks at the crash site earlier today

    Spain’s high-speed rail network is the second largest in the world after China’s.

    But this is the country’s second major high-speed rail disaster with multiple fatalities in less than a year, following the crash in Adamuz in January, in which 46 people were killed.

    While most parties suspended campaigning today, and Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez and other political leaders travelled to the crash site, the political implications of the accident are likely to linger throughout the election campaign.

    Sánchez has called a snap election for 29 November, hoping to turn the vote into something of a referendum on housing policy.

    Many political analysts saw that as favourable terrain for the prime minister.

    But a debate about the state of Spain’s infrastructure and the safety of its rail network could prove more challenging for Sánchez, who has been in power for the past eight years.

  16. Protesters gather outside transport ministry in Madridpublished at 19:48 GMT 28 October

    Protesters are shown gathering in Madrid behind a banner in Spanish that translates as "Criminals in power under the '78 regime". They are waving Spanish flags.Image source, Getty Images

    We're getting pictures through now of a protest outside the Ministry of Transport and Sustainable Mobility in Madrid.

    Protesters are demanding accountability over the train crash, which killed at least 68 people and left dozens more injured.

    Their banner criticises "criminals in power under the '78 regime" - a term used to refer to Spain's current political system, which emerged following the death of dictator Francisco Franco in 1975.

  17. Trade union calls on transport minister to resignpublished at 19:33 GMT 28 October

    Spanish trade union CSIF is demanding the resignation of Transport Minister Óscar Puente following today's high-speed train collision.

    In a statement, it accuses Puente of "scapegoating" a traffic manager during his press conference earlier today instead of "taking responsibility".

    "The minister has shirked all responsibility despite the initial computer system failure that triggered the events," CSIF adds.

    Earlier, we brought you comments from the transport minister in which he said it was "inexplicable" that a control centre allowed the high-speed train to start moving again after a computer failure, when another train was stationary on the tracks further ahead.

    Transport Minister Óscar Puente is shown speaking at a press conference, gesturing with his hands.Image source, EPA/Shutterstock
    Image caption,

    Transport Minister Óscar Puente speaks at a press conference earlier

  18. Passengers were 'breaking windows to get out'published at 19:24 GMT 28 October

    Salvador Arriza is pictured speaking to Reuters, with a group of people in the background talking to each other.Image source, Reuters

    Salvador Arriza, 62, says that the fact that he was travelling in the opposite direction to the train he was on saved him from being thrown out, like other passengers.

    "I was very close to the door, but [other passengers] were breaking the windows to be able to get out," he tells Reuters.

    The 62-year-old describes scenes of wreckage, with seats ripped out through the carriage where he was sitting near the back of the high-speed Renfe train.

    "Some people practically couldn't move because they were trapped amongst the seats," he says.

  19. Here's how the fatal collision unfoldedpublished at 19:14 GMT 28 October

    Timeline infographic showing a train collision near Urda, Toledo. An Iryo 6076 train left Madrid Atocha at 07:54 with 147 passengers, followed by Renfe AVE 2080 at 08:00 with 397 passengers. Just before 09:00, the AVE train struck the rear of the stationary Iryo train. The diagram shows several Iryo carriages and part of the AVE train derailing, with some carriages falling down an embankment.
  20. 'We were all thrown into the air,' recounts wounded passengerpublished at 19:02 GMT 28 October

    Rafael Barceló is pictured speaking to Reuters in a rural setting, with a visible wound on his forehead.Image source, Reuters

    Rafael Barceló was travelling in the high-speed AVE train that crashed.

    He says he was in the cafeteria car and that may have saved him and a friend from suffering the worst of the impact.

    “We were having breakfast, having a coffee and we felt a huge impact, we were all thrown into the air," he tells Reuters, with a visible wound on his forehead.

    "I am reasonably OK, my friend is quite worse.”

    Their seats were in car number seven, "which is the one with more victims and the one most destroyed," Barceló says.

    "I at least counted eight victims in that coach."