Summary

Media caption,
Watch: Genocide judgement will mean a great deal for Rohingya community, Jonathan Head reports
  1. Huge crowd in Rohingya refugee camp in Bangladesh watches verdictpublished at 10:32 GMT 19 November

    BBC Burmese Service

    A large crowd at a Rohingya refugee camp in Bangladesh are closely watching the ICJ verdict - as pictured here.

    A large crowd of men sat down watching the verdictImage source, Khin Mg
    Taken from behind a large crowd of people watching a screen showing the verdictImage source, Khin Mg
  2. A guilty ruling could have huge global repercussionspublished at 10:29 GMT 19 November

    Anna Holligan
    Reporting from The Hague

    A judgment against Myanmar would clarify how the ICJ proves genocidal intent - the decisive legal element - especially where atrocities include sexual violence, destruction of homes and villages, and mass displacement rather than a single straightforward pattern of mass killing.

    Legal experts expect future parties to cite the court’s approach to circumstantial and indirect evidence.

    It would also reinforce the principle that any state that's bound by the Genocide Convention can bring a case against another state, even if its own nationals were not directly harmed.

    The most closely watched is South Africa’s case against Israel over the war in Gaza. Parties and judges there could draw on the Myanmar ruling’s treatment of intent, the weight given to UN fact-finding findings, and the relevance of sexual violence and attacks on women and children in establishing a genocidal campaign.

  3. ICJ judge outlining how court reached judgment - but no verdict yetpublished at 10:25 GMT 19 November

    Side view of the panel of judges and members of the ICJ sat in front of them at the ICJImage source, EPA/Shutterstock
    Image caption,

    The scene inside the International Court of Justice (ICJ)

    If you're just joining us, over the past hour we've been listening to Judge Iwasawa Yuji lay out the International Court of Justice (ICJ) workings.

    Iwasawa is explaining how the court reached a judgment on whether Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya population.

    We will continue bringing you key lines and analysis.

    The ICJ's verdict has not yet been shared in court.

  4. Hate speech portrayed Rohingya as 'sub-human,' court hearspublished at 10:19 GMT 19 November

    Judge Iwasawa is now speaking in more detail about anti-Rohingya hate-speech.

    The court found that the Myanmar military "actively disseminated and promoted hate speech in a systematic and coordinated way" during its 2017 clearance operations.

    The ICJ notes an "overlap" between an "anti-Rohingya hate speech campaign" and the clearance operations.

    Iwasawa says the hate speech portrayed the Rohingya as "sub-human" and "a violent threat" which contributed to a "climate conducive to targeting a group for destruction".

  5. Number of Rohingya targeted by Myanmar is 'significant'published at 10:10 GMT 19 November

    The court finds that approximately 815,000 Rohingya who lived in the northern Rakhine state before the 2017 clearance operation were targeted by Myanmar.

    "This number is clearly significant," the judge says.

    Based on its size, the group targeted by Myanmar is considered "substantial" for the purposes of the Genocide Convention, he adds.

  6. Myanmar policies aimed to slow Rohingya birth rate, says judgepublished at 10:07 GMT 19 November

    Judge Iwasawa has spoken of ways in which restrictions against the Rohingya group impacted birth rates.

    Iwasawa recalls that Myanmar imposed regional order which required "special marriage permission requirements for people described as Bengalis, and limited the number of children married couples were allowed to have" - to two children.

    While the policies didn't succeed in restricting Rohingya birth rate, Myanmar accepts that the measure's purpose was to slow the birth rate in this group, Iwasawa explains.

    "Under these circumstances, the court is convinced that the order was a coercive measure directed at the Rohingya group, which was intended at the very least to reduce birth within the group including at the time of the clearance operations", the judge adds.

    This, alongside other measures, are "indicative" of the state's intent to stop the Rohingya group from reproducing.

    He also cites the use of sexual violence during clearance operations, which he says were intended to "physically and mentally impair the willingness and ability of the population to procreate".

  7. A majority of judges is enough to make a decisionpublished at 09:57 GMT 19 November

    Anna Holligan
    Reporting from The Hague

    We've been watching the judgment being announced by the ICJ's president, Yuji Iwasawa of Japan.

    He sits on a panel alongside 14 other elected judges from around the world. Because neither The Gambia nor Myanmar has a judge of its own nationality on the court, each has chosen an additional judge for this case: The Gambia selected Nobel laureate Navi Pillay, while Myanmar selected Claus Kress.

    Decisions are taken by majority vote; if the judges are evenly divided, the president has the casting vote.

  8. Judge outlines a state's obligation to prevent and punish genocidepublished at 09:54 GMT 19 November

    ICJ Judge Iwasawa has turned to state parties' responsibilities to prevent and punish genocide.

    He says the court recognises that a state may be held responsible for genocide or other acts if such acts are committed "by its organs, or by persons or groups whose acts are attributable to it [the state]".

    While individuals face criminal responsibility, states face obligations, he points out.

    Judge Iwasawa says obligations are responsibilities under international law, but they are not of a criminal nature.

  9. Around 10,000 killed in crackdown, court sayspublished at 09:49 GMT 19 November

    The ICJ has determined that around 10,000 Rohingya were "violently killed during clearance operations" in 2017, according to the evidence they've seen, says Judge Iwasawa.

  10. Rohingya is a distinct ethnic group, judge tells courtpublished at 09:46 GMT 19 November

    Importantly, the judge has identified the Rohingya as a distinct ethnic group.

    He notes that they have a distinct language, art, and self-identify.

    There is evidence that they have been discriminated against by Myanmar "for decades", he adds, and they qualify as a protected group.

  11. Myanmar security forces killed 'thousands of Rohingya civilians', court findspublished at 09:40 GMT 19 November

    Judge Yuji delivering his speechImage source, United Nations

    Turning to events leading up to August 2017 "clearance operations", Judge Iwasawa says the ICJ "recognises Arsa's attacks on security outposts and civilians, including its burning of villages".

    As a reminder, Arsa is a Rohingya militant group.

    Iwasawa also says, however, that the evidence establishes "Myanmar's security forces engaged in indiscriminate killings, separation and execution of men, sexual violence, and the deliberate burning of Rohingya homes" in certain locations.

    The judge adds that the court finds Myanmar security forces "killed thousands of Rohingya civilians, perpetrated widespread acts of sexual violence, as well as acts of extreme violence against children and attacked fleeing Rohingya as they sought to flee in large numbers to Bangladesh".

  12. Military-sponsored hate speech fuelled hostility against Rohingya - judgepublished at 09:31 GMT 19 November

    Judge Iwasawa is now reading out a summary of the ICJ's findings.

    The court observes that the Rohingya have been present in Myanmar for generations.

    In regards to the group's historical treatment, Judge Iwasawa says: "The court finds that discriminatory laws and restrictions progressively eroded their rights and left them marginalised and particularly vulnerable, while military-sponsored hate speech fuelled hostility against them".

  13. Myanmar failed to investigate alleged atrocities, says judgepublished at 09:24 GMT 19 November

    Next, Judge Iwasawa points to Myanmar's lack of co-operation.

    "In assessing the evidence, the court takes account of Myanmar's failure genuinely to investigate the alleged atrocities and its refusal to facilitate access to evidence and witnesses to provide information requested".

    Myanmar's Union Minister for the Ministry of the President's Office Ko Ko Hlaing sat next to a lawyer in the ICJImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    Ko Ko Hlaing, a Myanmar government representative, pictured in the ICJ as the judge delivers the verdict

  14. ICJ judge outlines how the court approached its verdictpublished at 09:21 GMT 19 November

    Judge Iwasawa Yuji, President of the Court, is laying out the background to this case and how it has approached making a judgment.

    Judge Iwasawa explains that in this case the ICJ does not have comparable judicial decisions to support its findings, as it did in previous genocide rulings.

    Therefore, he says the ICJ "can only rely on the evidence provided by the parties to make its own determination of the facts".

    The court will consider witness testimonies and witness cases, the judge explains, including its form and the circumstances in which the statements were made.

    Fear for reprisals from those who gave evidence is another factor the court is taking into consideration, he adds.

    During oral proceedings, Iwasawa says the court heard from four witnesses who had experienced violence in the last week of August 2017.

    "The court found The Gambia's witnesses credible in their account of the particular events to which they testified," he says.

    "Many of the witnesses' key statements were unchallenged in cross-examination".

    Gambia's Justice Minister and Attorney General Dawda JalloImage source, Reuters
    Image caption,

    The Gambia delegation, who filed the case with the ICJ, pictured at the ICJ on Thursday

  15. What impact will the verdict have on Rohingya refugees?published at 09:16 GMT 19 November

    Jonathan Head
    South East Asia correspondent

    "This is like formal recognition of our suffering," says Mohammed Nowkim, a Rohingya who was driven out of the Rakhine town of Buthidaung in 2017 and now lives in Canada.

    "For the Rohingya, this trial is a moment of acknowledgement of our suffering after years of denial. The Rohingya have been waiting for justice for decades, not just this year."

    He and other Rohingya activists hope that a ruling in favour of The Gambia will prompt more co-ordinated action by other countries to find a resolution which allows them to go home to Rakhine State, in safety.

    More than a million are stuck in wretched camps in Bangladesh, barred from employment as international funding dries up.

    But the obstacles to realising this hope are formidable.

    Rohingya refugees at a camp in Cox's Bazar.Image source, Getty Images
    Image caption,

    More than a million Rohingya refugees live in Bangladesh's Cox's Bazar

    Rakhine State has been ravaged by a conflict between the military and the insurgent Arakan Army, which now controls most of the territory. It is supported by the indigenous Rakhine population who are very hostile to the idea of the Rohingyas coming back.

    Many Rohingya villages have been completely destroyed. And international support for them has faded over the years. Even an unprecedented genocide verdict at the world's highest court cannot change that reality.

  16. Crowds gather at Rohingya refugee camp to watch the verdictpublished at 09:09 GMT 19 November

    BBC Burmese Service

    Large crowds of displaced refugees have gathered to watch the International Court of Justice's decision on whether Myanmar committed genocide against the Rohingya minority.

    These pictures were taken at a Rohingya refugee camp in Bangladesh.

    Dozens of men stand in a crowd in front of refugee tentsImage source, Khin Mg
    Two men stand next to a screen showing an image of the ICJ in The HagueImage source, Khin Mg
    Large crowd of men facing the screen where the verdict will be shownImage source, Khin Mg
    Empty red chairs in front of a screen showing the verdictImage source, Khin Mg
  17. ICJ starts delivering its judgmentpublished at 09:05 GMT 19 November
    Breaking

    The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has begun the session in which it will deliver a judgment on whether Myanmar committed a genocide against the Rohingya community.

    We'll bring you the latest from the Hague - stay with us.

  18. 'The only hope for us to return home'published at 08:48 GMT 19 November

    Anna Holligan
    Reporting from The Hague

    Rohingya child psychiatrist Ambia Parveen standing outside court

    Rohingya child psychiatrist Ambia Parveen is outside the International Court of Justice, which is located at the Peace Palace in The Hague, Netherlands.

    She says she wants "recognition and accountability for our children".

    "The world should know we have a voice," Parveen says. "When you give us the microphone, we will speak out."

    Sayedul Karim, a Rohingya man wearing a suit, stands outside the International Court of Justice

    Sayedul Karim, founder of the Rohingya Justice Initiative, says this case is the "only hope for us returning home".

    A group of people outside the International Court of Justice
    Image caption,

    The court in The Hague is due to being delivering its verdict at 1000 local time (0900 GMT)

  19. The ICJ has ruled twice before on genocide casespublished at 08:40 GMT 19 November

    The ICJ has ruled on genocide cases twice before:

    1. Bosnia v Serbia (2007): The ICJ found one act of genocide during Bosnia's 1992-95 war: the massacre of about 8,000 Bosnian Muslim (Bosniak) men and boys by Bosnian Serb forces in the town of Srebrenica in 1995. The court ruled that Serbia had failed to prevent the killings, but absolved it of direct responsibility.
    2. Croatia v Serbia (2015): The Croatian government alleged that Serbia committed genocide in the town of Vukovar and elsewhere in 1991. Serbia later filed a counter-claim over the expulsion of more than 200,000 Serbs from Croatia in 1995. The ICJ rejected both claims.
  20. No state ever found guilty by international court of committing genocidepublished at 08:31 GMT 19 November

    Jonathan Head
    South East Asia correspondent

    In the years since the Genocide Convention was signed in 1948, after the Nazi Holocaust, dozens of individuals have been successfully prosecuted for the crime of genocide, in conflicts such as those in Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia.

    But no state has ever been found guilty by an international court of committing genocide.

    Historically, proving that genocide has been committed has been very difficult. Judges apply a high bar to this.

    Typically, where there is no explicitly genocidal programme, like that of the Nazis, the judges require that the evidence presented at court must be such that the only reasonable inference from the actions of the defendants is that they had genocidal intent.

    When Bosnia-Herzegovina filed a genocide case against Serbia at the ICJ in 1993, it took the court 14 years to conclude that while incidents like the 1995 massacre at Srebrenica did amount to genocide, there was not sufficient proof that the state of Serbia had genocidal intent, though it was found to have failed to prevent genocide.