Summary

  • The state of NHS Grampian was raised at FMQs, prompting John Swinney to say that fresh allegations are of the "gravest concern"

  • Thursday's Q&A came days after Health Secretary Angela Constance made a statement in the Scottish Parliament about leadership failings at the health board

  • Hours before FMQs, a surgeon went public about the unnecessary deaths of patients following surgeries at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary

  • Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra accused the FM of knowing how bad the situation was and did "nothing". He went on to urge the Lord Advocate to launch a criminal prosecution

  • Scottish Conservative leader Russell Findlay echoed those words, arguing that Swinney was told three times about the "industrial scale" problems and did "nothing"

  • When Swinney was asked if he would have an operation at the Aberdeen Royal Infirmary he said "yes", adding that patients should be confident that their safety was of paramount importance

  • Scotland's UK Reform leader Malcolm Offord asked the FM about the "crisis" of young people not in work; Scottish Green leader Gillian Mackay asked about NHS Grampian and data centres and Scottish Lib Dem leader Alex Cole-Hamilton raised the problematic IT systems used at GP surgeries and by other public bodies

  • Watch live by clicking on the play button above

  1. Background: Surgeon calls for corporate homicide probe over claims patients unnecessarily bled to deathpublished at 14:03 GMT 19 November

    Dr Mohammed Habib has grey hair and glasses and is wearing a black suit jacket and a white and blue checked shirt
    Image caption,

    Dr Mohammed Habib has been raising concerns for a decade

    A consultant surgeon at Aberdeen Royal Infirmary has called for a corporate homicide investigation into claims of avoidable deaths among NHS Grampian patients over many years.

    Dr Mohammed Habib, who is still a surgeon at the hospital, said he had been raising concerns for a decade, including with government ministers and police, but he had been ignored.

    The whistleblowing medic also leaked an unpublished expert review from 2022 which found 19 avoidable deaths among 45 patients in liver and pancreatic surgery, including some who bled to death in the operating theatre because of mistakes by surgeons.

    The allegations come a week after a scathing report found poor leadership and culture at the NHS Grampian board. The board's management is yet to comment on these latest public claims.

    Last week, Healthcare Improvement Scotland (HIS) found "major deficiencies" across the region and revealed that a failure to learn from mistakes had caused "repeated and avoidable harm" to patients.

    Health Secretary Angela Constance insisted facilities were safe and there would be "full transparency" at every level.

    Read more.

  2. NHS Grampian: Why has this happened?published at 14:03 GMT 19 November

    Scottish Labour leader Michael Marra kicks off FMQs by bringing up the "horrific revelations" about avoidable deaths at NHS Grampian and asks John Swinney why has this happened?

  3. Welcomepublished at 13:46 GMT 19 November

    Good afternoon and welcome to our live coverage of First Minister's Questions on Thursday 19 November.

    John Swinney will face questions from his opposition leaders for half an hour from about 14.00.

    You can follow events in the chamber by clicking on the Watch live icon at the top of this page.