Juno and the Paycock - Themes - CCEA

Part of English LiteratureJuno and the Paycock

Applicable context

  • Sean O’Casey was born in 1880 into a large Protestant family in Dublin – he was christened John Casey but later altered his name to its Gaelic approximation to show his allegiance to Irish language and culture. The death of his father when he was six meant his mother held the family together by herself; they had to move house many times when he was a child and he saw many examples of the kinds of tenement apartments in which his characters live. He taught himself to read and write by his early teens and left school at 14 to begin work in a variety of jobs including labouring, delivering newspapers and working on railways.
  • In his twenties, O’Casey became involved with Irish cultural organisations; he became a speaker of the Irish language and sympathised with the Irish cause. He also became involved with set up to protect the rights of unskilled labourers in the Dublin tenements; at one point, his participation in a lengthy and significant industrial strike severely harmed his ability to find work. He remained committed to principles throughout his life, but gradually became very sceptical of the motives of Irish nationalism and the suspicion that it cared more for romantic ideals than the real problems faced by poor and working class people. He began writing in 1917 after his friend, a revolutionary involved in the , died on a hunger strike.
  • Ireland was a colonised land and had a long history of conflict between British government forces and those who wanted Ireland’s independence restored. Although there had been many attempts over the years to overthrow British rule, things accelerated in the early twentieth century for a number of reasons, including the Irish Cultural Revival and fears of the possible conscription of young Irish men into the British forces in World War One. The took place in Dublin in 1916 – it was another attempted revolution which was defeated by the British in immediate terms, but sparked more unrest and violence. In the years that followed, Ireland became a battleground: first during the and then in the . The Civil War was a conflict between Irish nationalists in 1922-23 over whether to accept or reject the Anglo-Irish Treaty that had been negotiated with the British government. Juno and the Paycock is set during this harrowing time in Irish history, which saw families and communities turned against each other. The play was first performed at the Abbey Theatre in March 1924, only two years after it was set; it is important to remember that the audience then – so close to the Irish Civil War – would have reacted very differently from how an audience today might react.
Back to top

Themes in Juno and the Paycock

O’Casey uses Dublin during the Irish Civil War as a setting for the play. This was a time of difficulty, conflict and change, which allows him to explore a variety of themes. The main themes in Juno and the Paycock are:

  • poverty
  • religion
  • the horror of war
  • gender inequality
  • deception

Back to top

Poverty

It is obvious from the opening stage directions that the Boyle family is not well off. As the play progresses, it becomes clear that they have barely enough money to survive. They live in a building, part of the Dublin slums.

There is little room for four adults. The audience sees “a small bed partly concealed by hangings strung on a twine” in the same room as the dining table and the bath. These cramped claustrophobic surroundings become a symbol for the conditions many people in Dublin lived in at this time.

In 1961, the Irish socialist and trade union leader noted that Dublin’s slums were:

“…notorious the world over for their disease-breeding unhealthy character. All the world over it is known that the poor of Dublin are housed under conditions worse than those of any civilised people on God’s earth.”

It seems that O’Casey’s main intention in the play was to show the reality of these conditions. He questions whether the Irish nationalist cause and all its promises really made anything better for Dublin’s poor and needy.

Juno is the only one in the household working. Mary is on strike, Johnny is not well and Captain Boyle is too lazy to do any work at all. He spends most of his time drinking any money he gets his hands on. There are repeated references to unemployment throughout the play. It is painfully clear that the family do not have much income. Juno is even unwilling to share tea with Joxer as they have so little themselves.

The promise of inherited money changes everything, as they immediately begin to see the possibility of a life free of poverty. When this turns out to have been a lie, their poverty seems even worse as the dreams and hopes they had disappear.

The family members try to escape their situation. Boyle retreats into alcohol and self-delusion while Mary strikes and reads Ibsen. She also embraces a feminine world of being concerned with beauty (symbolised by the ribbons) and seeming to find love with a more wealthy man. Johnny turns to the Irish republican cause, an escape taken by many working-class men who thought they could change things for the better.

Poverty means they struggle in life, and may continue to struggle as long as they live. There is a hint of hope in the fact that perhaps – because it will have Juno who actually works, and Mary who reads and tries to improve herself – the baby will have some chance of escaping these conditions in the future.

Back to top

Religion

There are many references to religion throughout the play and the characters have a variety of religious views. For example, Juno is a traditional Catholic and Bentham is a . Mary seems to be more in her views. She proclaims, “There isn’t a God, there isn’t a God; if there was He wouldn’t let these things happen.”

Many characters resort to prayer in times of distress – for example, when Johnny is being dragged out to be murdered, and when Mrs Tancred and Juno are seeking comfort: “Sacred Heart o’ Jesus, take away our hearts o’ stone.”

Johnny takes comfort in religion, despite not seeming to be a very religious person. For instance, he feels safe if the light remains lit under the picture of the Virgin Mary. However, this light could be symbolic of hope and less to do with his faith in the protection of God.

Boyle expresses many anti-religious opinions, seeming to believe that the church does not always have the best of intentions and that people who seem very religious were often not as moral in their everyday actions. He composes an amusing poem which highlights the of those who attend mass and openly profess a love of God while behaving differently in their lives: “He was not what some call pious - seldom at church or prayer; For the greatest scoundrels I know, sir, goes every Sunday there.”

He also believes that "the clergy always had too much power over the people in this unfortunate country". Perhaps Boyle is echoing O’Casey’s own beliefs about a country with little separation between church and state. Although O’Casey’s Protestant mother brought him up in her own religion, he eventually became an . Boyle’s voice may be the voice of O’Casey himself on this topic.

Back to top

Nationalism

While focused on the Irish Civil War and the nationalist cause, this is by no means a nationalist play. O’Casey looks at the and the nationalist cause with a very critical eye.

He had become disillusioned with the cause because he believed the nationalists put their nationalism before socialism, forgetting about the everyday working lives of the poor people of Ireland. O’Casey was more concerned with presenting the poverty and alienation faced by the working-class inhabitants of Dublin slums than he was with nationalist ideals. He believed that nationalism and the call to take up arms for one’s country was in fact bad for working-class people. O’Casey himself had worked as a labourer and was well aware of the lack of rights and opportunities open to the working-classes. He became a member of the Irish Transport and General Workers’ Union (ITGWU), writing articles for the Irish Worker, a newspaper founded by James Connolly.

Therefore, the play is not biased towards nationalism. Instead, O'Casey dramatises the impoverished living conditions and stressful lives of Dubliners without idealising nationalists or . The , for example, are not portrayed in a positive light. The men who come to take Johnny away for execution are rude and violent.

O’Casey himself did not approve of the patriotic glorification of violence, something explored in his other plays. He considered it at odds with improving the lives of the working class. This is seen in the play, where Johnny’s idealistic political views trap him in a life of fear and violence. When the play begins we see that he has already lost an arm due to an injury he sustained in the Easter Rising. When the Mobilizer comes for him at the end of Act Two, Johnny cries "Haven't I done enough for Ireland! I've lost me arm, an' me hip's desthroyed so that I'll never be able to walk right agen! Good God, haven't I done enough for Ireland?" The young man replies, "Boyle, no man can do enough for Ireland!"

However, O’Casey’s disillusionment with this patriotic call to bear arms is echoed in other plays from his Dublin trilogy. For example, in ‘Shadow of a Gunman’, a character named Seamus Shields remarks in Act Two: “It’s the civilians that suffer; when there’s an ambush they don’t know where to run. Shot in the back to save the British Empire, an’ shot in the breast to save the soul of Ireland … I believe in the freedom of Ireland, an’ that England has no right to be here, but I draw the line when I hear the gunmen blowin’ about dyin’ for the people, when it’s the people that are dyin’ for the gunmen!”. Perhaps this is O’Casey’s real response to those who suggest "no man can do enough for Ireland".

Back to top

The horror of war

O’Casey shows the horrors of war through the tragic effect of Ireland's Civil War on ordinary families.

The action of the play is entirely within the domestic setting of the Boyles’ home, but even so, the impact of the war is devastating. Two mothers lose their sons. Through the grief expressed by these women, O’Casey shows that death is horrific regardless of how worthy the cause may seem.

Again, we see this attitude in one of his other plays in the Dublin trilogy. In The Plough and the Stars, Nora Clitheroe asserts that “There’s no woman gives a son or a husband to be killed - if they say it, they’re lyin’, lyin’, against God, Nature, an’ against themselves!” (The plough and the Stars by Seán O'Casey, Act Three). This also seems to show O’Casey’s belief that no one gladly gave their lives or the lives of loved ones for any cause. The brutal murders of Robbie Tancred and Johnny Boyle, along with the effects those deaths have on their families, demonstrate the futility of the war.

O'Casey shows that there is not much support for the families affected. The Irish police are of little help, as Mrs Madigan asserts:

For you're the same as yous were undher the British Government - never where yous are wanted! As far as I can see, the Polis as Polis, in this city, is Null an' Void!.

Act Three

O'Casey draws on his experience of living through these events and shows that those who feel it is their duty to fight for their country are rarely given any thanks or reward, especially the working classes.

The constant fear and psychological trauma Johnny experiences throughout the play – a fear we come to realise is not irrational but understandable – shows the consequences for many of those who contributed to the nationalist cause, even if they did survive.

Back to top

Gender inequality

The male and female characters stand in stark contrast to one another:

  • The women in the play are shown as more and intelligent than the men, who are often self-centered and cowardly.
  • The men resort to alcohol, nationalist dreams and violence while the women are shown to be stronger and wiser.
  • The women in the play suffer because of the actions, and inaction, of the men. This shows how little power over their own lives women had in Ireland at that time.

Mary is vain, but she has passion. This is demonstrated by her principled decision to go on strike on someone else’s behalf. Her , on the other hand, are self-centered and desert her in her time of need.

She is a young woman born into poverty with a lazy, "hopeless" father. Yet she shows a desire to get out of the slums through reading and educating herself. She is obviously an intelligent woman and her strike action shows that she is willing to stand up for her beliefs. However, in the end she is let down by all the male characters and their lack of strength, integrity and compassion:

  • Bentham abandons her without a goodbye
  • Jerry Devine rejects her when he finds out she is pregnant
  • her own brother and father scorn her for bringing "disgrace" to the house

It is only the other women in the play who stand by her. Juno promises "If Mary goes, I’ll go with her." The men in the play do nothing for Mary in her time of need.

The most detailed contrast is between Juno and Boyle. Her hard-working nature is contrasted with his idleness in the opening scenes. He spends all his time and money drinking with Joxer and accuses his pregnant daughter of bringing shame on the family, rather than supporting her in her plight.

In contrast, Juno feeds the family, stands by Mary and grieves desperately for her dead son. The strength of the female characters – particularly with the male ones – reflects a perspective in O'Casey's plays. Juno herself wonders "is there not even a middlin’ honest man left in th’ world" as she laments the disappearance of any decent men.

Despite the nature of the men in the play we see that the female characters are blamed – much as Eve has been since the Book of Genesis in the Bible – for the misfortunes that befall the characters.

Mary is disgraced for the pregnancy, despite Bentham’s role in it. She has to accept the scorn and live with the stigma. Even her mother assumes that it is Mary’s fault that Bentham has gone without a word and asks her “Are you sure you said nothin’ to him?” Meanwhile, despite her feeding, clothing and soothing him in his time of need, Johnny says to Juno in the end: “You’re to blame yourself for a gradle of it - givin’ him his own way”.

Perhaps O’Casey is commenting on the unfortunate position of women in society and the expectation that they be the backbone of families, and yet be treated as scapegoats for all the misfortunes of men. This certainly seems to be the case when Juno finally rejects her previous beliefs that everything that happens is the will of God and says, "These things have nothin’ to do with the Will o’ God. Ah, what can God do agen the stupidity o’ men!"

Back to top

Deception

Characters in Juno and the Paycock regularly deceive and are regularly deceived. Both Mary and Johnny are deceived into thinking that sticking to their ‘principles’ will improve their position in life. This may have been O’Casey showing his disillusionment with both the nationalist and the socialist causes.

Despite needing her job, Mary strikes to support the trade unions, meaning she is receiving no pay in order to support the cause. Johnny has been deceived into thinking the sacrifices he made risking his life during the Easter Rising would be worthwhile. By the end of the play Johnny’s has led to his execution and Mary has been abandoned by her fiancé while pregnant with his child.

Mrs Boyle, however, seems to echo the disillusionment of O’Casey himself as she is more of a realist. She is not convinced by the idea that having principles will automatically improve the lives of her children. She asks Mary what the local shopkeeper would say if she told him a “principle’s a principle” and informs Johnny that “you lost your best principle, me boy, when you lost your arm”.

Mary is betrayed by Bentham and even Juno incredulously questions how he could "go away t’ England, an’ not to even leave you his address”. Mrs Boyle herself has been taken in by Bentham. She admits, “I thought he was mad afther you". Because of his class and education both women believed that he was trustworthy and reliable. Despite the way he has treated Mary, Mrs Boyle remains deceived by Bentham’s class into considering him to be respectable – she refers to him as “a man like Mr. Bentham” even after he has left.

We see Boyle believing that people are real friends, especially after he finds out about his windfall. Right from the beginning we see him putting his trust in Joxer Daly who ridicules him behind his back when he wonders “who, in the name o’ God, ud leave anythin’ to that oul’ bummer?”. Joxer sneers at the family's misfortune: “Sure they were bound to get a dhrop!”

Boyle himself, of course, shows a similar fickle attitude to his supposed best friend Joxer, whom he is quick to denounce the minute he finds out about his inheritance.

The inheritance changes things for the Boyles and their neighbours. The family are fooled into thinking Mrs Madigan is a friend, but instead she is only interested in profiting from Boyle’s inheritance. She physically assaults him when it is clear she will not be able to do so. Her anger is shown when she asserts “You’re not goin’ to be swankin’ it like a paycock with Maisie Madigan’s money.” Everyone who befriended the Boyles when there was money to be made from their good fortune rejects them as soon as they find out they have nothing.

Aside from characters deceiving each other or being deceived by others, there are elements of self-deception in the play – for example, Boyle’s oblivious tendency to think himself much grander, better and more deserving than he is. His constant leads him to believe the lies and exaggerations he presents as his real self; he is so used to thinking of himself as wonderful and telling others how good he is, that he is actually deceived by his own ‘hype’. At the end of the play we see him carrying on as usual, completely unaware that his whole family is now gone – his self-deception carries on, obscuring the real truth from him.

Back to top

Test yourself

Back to top

Further study

The Sunday Play: Juno and the Paycock (pt.1) audio

Listen to part one of Seán O'Casey's best-loved play, set in Dublin in 1922, with BBC Sounds.

The Sunday Play: Juno and the Paycock (pt.1)

The Sunday Play: Juno and the Paycock (pt. 2) audio

Listen to part two of Seán O'Casey's best-loved play, set in Dublin in 1922, with BBC Sounds.

The Sunday Play: Juno and the Paycock (pt. 2)

The Sunday Play: Juno and the Paycock (pt. 3) audio

Listen to part three of Seán O'Casey's best-loved play, set in Dublin in 1922, with BBC Sounds.

The Sunday Play: Juno and the Paycock (pt. 3)
Back to top