Lake District: land use conflicts and solutions

Part of GeographyGlaciated upland landscapes

Quick version

The Lake District is a popular tourist destination but the large numbers of tourists can create issues that cause conflict with different groups, including farmers, such as:

  • gates left open allow livestock to escape
  • loose dogs endanger sheep
  • stone walls are damaged by people climbing over them
  • noise and crowds can disturb animals
  • visitors object to farmers blocking access

Local people can also find themselves in conflict with tourists:

  • litter detracts from the appearance of the area
  • large numbers of visitors cause traffic congestion and pollution on local roads
  • footpaths used by locals are eroded and damaged by high numbers of visitors
  • housing used for holiday homes reduces year-round use of local services

Other conflicts exist relating to:

  • conservation vs access to the environment
  • tourist traffic vs local use of roads
  • renewable energy vs visual pollution
A stopwatch with speed lines
Back to top

Conflict 1: tourists vs farmers

As there are many different landowners and land users in the Lake District, conflicts can arise. More conflict occurs in summer, due to the arrival of large numbers of tourists to the area.

Tourists visiting the landscape often come into conflict with farmers who own and work the land.

Below you will find some solutions designed to minimise the conflicts arising between farmers and tourists.

Problems followed by solutions: Gates left open - signs, dogs chase sheep - park rangers employed, stone walls damaged - volunteer maintenance, restricted access - alternatives planned, noise scares animals - outdoor access code

Click here for a text version of the above information in a table.

Image gallerySkip image gallerySlide 1 of 3, A farm gate is left open as a walker heads down a path without closing it behind them , Gates left open can allow livestock to escape. This can endanger animals and cause extra work for farmers.
Back to top

Conflict 2: tourists vs locals

Problems can also arise between tourists and locals in the Lake District.

Here are some of the key conflicts with solutions which can be adopted to help everyone using the land.

Problems followed by solutions: Increased litter - take litter home, traffic congestion - one way systems, footpath erosion - stone paths built, noise pollution - improve public transport, holiday homes don't support services all year - mobile services for villages

Click here for a text version of the above information in a table.

Image gallerySkip image gallerySlide 1 of 3, Please take your Litter home sign Lake District National Park, The National Park authorities have removed litter bins to encourage people to take their litter home
Back to top

Conflict 3: conflicts involving local people

Transport

The nature of the Lake District landscape means there are not many big roads and these can quickly become busy and difficult to navigate during busy seasons and around attractions.

ProblemsSolutions
High volumes of traffic through towns and on country roads causes congestion, noise and pollution, as well as increasing travel times for locals and visitors.Additional public transport services are in place during weekends and holidays. Visitors can travel on the Lakeside & Haverthwaite Steam Railway.
Some areas of the Lakes are difficult to access without your own transport, increasing the number of cars.Bicycle rental or touring is encouraged as another way to visit the Lake District. Signed routes encourage more cycling as a way to see many parts of the National Park.
Slow moving farm vehicles can cause delays for visitors.Improved public transport has been introduced in the Lake District to reduce the effect of traffic congestion.
Visitors parking in gateways/on narrow roads can disrupt access for famers/foresters.Farmers are encouraged to provide clear signs to indicate access restrictions

Conservation

Encouraging access to the Lake District and supporting local farmers and employment are key aims of the National Park, These need to be balanced with the needs of conservation and protecting the landscape and its wildlife.

ProblemsSolutions
Litter dropped by walkers can harm livestock and wildlife.National Park rangers patrol areas and issue fines for littering.
Footpaths can be closed temporarily to allow the vegetation to recover. This may annoy visitorsPark rangers put up signs and provide information on which areas are closed and why.
Pesticides and fertilisers used on farms may run off into rivers, affecting water quality and aquatic lifeCatchment Sensitive Farming schemes offer advice and grants to farmers to help them reduce pollution from their farms.
Large numbers of parked cars and coaches can be an eyesore.Screening car parks and coach parks helps preserve the look of the landscape.
Dog waste can be a health hazard to people and livestock. Plastic poo bags can be dangerous to livestock and wildlife.Owners should take dog waste away with them for disposal. Dogs should be wormed regularly to prevent them passing on parasites or infections.
New buildings and development can destroy the traditional character of villages and townsDesignated Conservation Areas have restrictions on what new building or alterations to existing buildings can be carried out
Development and large numbers of visitors can threaten or destroy wildlife habitatsAreas can be classed as Sites of Special Scientific Interest or Special Protected Areas to protect biodiversity. Nature reserves protect or restore habitats.

Renewable energy

Although renewable energy is a crucial part of combatting climate change, it is more complicated when it comes to finding the right space for this in a protected landscape.

ProblemsSolutions
Large scale energy projects are seen as an eye sore and can damage the landscape and wildlife habitatsThe National Park Authority encourages small scale and domestic renewable projects, such as 100KW hydroelectric scheme in the Greenburn valley, which can power 150 homes a year.
Local people do not see any benefit from energy projectsFor schemes run by the National Trust, electricity generated goes into the National Grid, and the money this earns is reinvested in our conservation work.
Back to top

Quiz

Back to top

Recap

The Lake District is a popular tourist destination - this can lead to a variety of conflicts arising between locals and tourists as well as tourists with farmers.

In addition these two groups also can have conflicts resulting from the shared land use with conservation, transport and renewable energy. The table below highlights some of the solutions to some of the main conflicts.

 A highlighter pen and sheet of writing with sections highlighted
ProblemsSolutions
Walkers leave gates open.Farmers display 'keep gate closed' signs.
Dogs chase sheep.Visitor centre staff aim to educate the public about the 'Countryside Code/Outdoor Access Code'.
Popular tourist areas may see damage to stone walls and vegetation over time as well as increased litter.Voluntary bodies, such as the National Trust, protect areas by buying land and buildings, and maintaining walls and footpaths.
Traffic congestion at peak times impedes locals going about their daily business.One-way systems (Ambleside), pedestrianised areas (Keswick) and improved public transport have been introduced to reduce the effect of traffic congestion.
Footpath erosion results in visual pollution in popular walking areas, eg on the mountain Helvellyn.National Park officers can build stone paths to reduce footpath erosion and put up signs to direct walkers along alternative routes.
More noise and air pollution from increased traffic.Rail and bus services have been improved to reduce the number of cars in the national park.
Services may close as second home owners are not permanent residents.Weekly vans providing services to small villages, eg mobile library.
Back to top