How new rules allow big six to spend even more

By
Football issues correspondent
  • Published

You might recall that Aston Villa and Newcastle were not fans of the old Profit and Sustainability rules (PSR), which forced both clubs to sell some of their best players to balance the books.

That has changed this season with squad-cost ratio (SCR).

There is a key difference with SCR in that it allows a club to spend the money they generate on players. PSR limited losses so was more restrictive.

Kieran Maguire, professor of football finance at the University of Liverpool said: "This does make it a little easier for the likes of Villa and Newcastle to spend money. But it is still heavily weighted in favour of the big six.

"SCR is different to PSR rather than better. For some people, change is advantageous. For others, it isn't."

So what does this mean?

The big six generate hundreds of millions of pounds more than the other clubs. So they can spend hundreds of millions of pounds more on their squads.

This makes the big six even more powerful in the transfer market.

"Look at the clubs who voted against SCR - Brighton, Brentford, Bournemouth, Crystal Palace, Fulham and Leeds," Maguire said.

"It's very noticeable that those clubs have traditionally been very good at player sales, while they have tended to have lower matchday and commercial revenues."

Most of the big six - the outlier being Chelsea - are not remotely close to the Premier League's 85% SCR limit.

Read more on how Premier League's big six keep getting richer here

Premier League squad-cost ratio levels
Based on 2024-25 accounting figures
Tottenham- 53.3%
Ipswich - 54.3%
Liverpool- 57.1%
Man City- 57.3%
Arsenal- 59.6%
Man Utd- 60.1%
Brighton - 62.4%
Southampton - 64.4%
Everton - 67.7%
Leicester - 68.7%
Brentford - 70.6%
Aston Villa - 72%
Crystal Palace- 74.1%
Nottm Forest - 75.8%
Newcastle - 75.8%
Bournemouth - 80.3%
Fulham - 82.3%
West Ham - 82.6%
Wolves - 83.2%
Chelsea - 83.5%
Source: Valuball
Revenue spent on squad costs