Main content

Actress Ruth Madeley: Hitting Hollywood and playing Judy Heumann

And the investigation into AI "touching up" images of people with facial difference.

UK actress Ruth Madeley might be a familiar face on your TV screens, but now she's become a Hollywood leading lady - and we're so excited!
 
Ruth plays Judy Heumann, mother of the US disability rights movement, in the film Being Heumann, alongside four-time Oscar-nominated, Mark Ruffalo.
 
It follows Judy as she leads the longest sit-in in a government building to ensure disabled people were given the rights to be included in society and no longer discriminated against, from the implementation of ramps into federal buildings to being able to attend mainstream school and kerb cuts.
 
With Hollywood, comes glamour, so we also hear about the top fashion designers now vying to have Ruth wear their clothes and the intimacy co-ordinators who ensured all those sexy scenes were done just so.
 
How would you feel if AI touched up a photo to make you look “normal”? It happened to Rhiannon, who has a facial difference, so BBC Wales investigated the extent of the problem. And listen out for a heads up on a new podcast on the UK disability rights movement.
 
Presented and produced by Emma Tracey
Series producer and presenter's friend is Beth Rose
Studio manager is Jonny Hall
Sound design is Mike Regaard
Editor is Damon Rose

Release date:

Available now

40 minutes

Featured

  • .

Transcript

EMMA: Hello, this is Access All. I'm Emma Tracey and coming up on this episode...

 

[Clip]

RUTH: I think I had croissant round my mouth. I had coffee in my hand. I was wearing his shirt. I had my hair piled up. I was like, oh my god, they're flying me to Paris for Louis Vuitton. And Joe just looked at me and was like, why… why?

[End of clip]

 

EMMA: That is film star Ruth Madeley on her love of fashion and the opportunities that playing Judy Heumann, mother of the disability rights movement in the US, have brought her. Lots more about the Being Heumann film and Judy Heumann herself in our chat very soon.

 Beth is here, Beth Rose, disability and mental health journalist at the BBC. Hello.

 

BETH: Hi Emma.

 

EMMA: We've both been on holiday!

 

BETH: We have. Not together, but we have both been away.

 

EMMA: Yes, so I was in Tenerife where there were an enormous number of very sexy looking scooters, mobility scooters. So like 2 seaters with like a boombox under the seat and ones that my husband said looked a bit like an old Vespa. And it was just, they were everywhere and there were big signs on them saying hire me.

 

BETH: I love the fact that they were hireable. So yeah, anyone who's having a bit of a tricky time, can get a really cool way to get around.

 

EMMA: We've been hearing from a colleague about their parent who's struggling with the idea of using one. And I just think if you could start by using one on your holidays in a different country and then come back and know what it's like and know that there are scooters that look like how you'd want your scooter to look, then maybe you'd be a bit more open to it.

 

BETH: I was in Hawaii, which was lovely, but one of the things we did is on the island of Oahu, we went to Pearl Harbour, which of course was attacked in World War II. There's the USS Missouri, where the peace treaty was signed for World War II, the submarines, there's a museum and all sorts. And it's a massive draw for veterans and their families. So you get all sorts of people that have maybe experienced injuries from the war or just are a lot older. I met a 94 year old there who was proudly wearing his veteran hat and jumper and they are treated like absolute royalty. And it's great because you can go and have a great chat with them about their experiences and all the life lessons they learned. cBut there were some great people watching just generally. cSo we went on this tour and my, now fiancé.

 

EMMA: Yes, congratulations!

 

BETH: Thank you so much. I was like, wasn't it an amazing tour? cAnd I was like, oh my gosh, yeah, I loved how much the tour guide hated that couple. And he was like, what? What about all these, historical artifacts? And I was like, no, it was just the people watching.

 

EMMA: Can't take you anywhere.

 

BETH: I know, I know.

 

EMMA: Did you read any books on holiday?

 

BETH: I read a couple of books. What about you?

 

EMMA: Well, before we left, I was out with a group of friends and one of them said that their book club was reading Fourth Wing. And it took me like 100, couple of 100 pages to realize that it is fully disability laden, it's this sexy dragons era that people talk about…

 

BETH: …romantasy right?

 

EMMA:… but the girl the main character has hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos syndrome which basically means that her joints come out really easily like dislocate and she's in a lot of pain every day, but she, her mother is like the general in this army and her mother has made her become a dragon rider. She was supposed to be a scribe, so she was supposed to be an academic. And what I love about it is like there have to be adjustments. So the dragon, they have to put a saddle on it. So nobody else uses a saddle on the dragon except for her because she can't hold her seat, as they say, because she can't like squish her knees in hard enough and like tense her legs. And then also the dragon makes a kind of a ramp for her up onto the saddle by the way he puts his leg down, whereas everyone else has to do it a different way, like take a running jump onto their dragon. But I think what I love is that all of the books I read about disability have been either sent to me to read for a story or everybody knows how obsessive I am about disability and mental health stuff, so they recommend. But this was accidentally recommended to me by a friendship group that has nothing to do with disability and that didn't even know that it was about disability. And that was my favourite thing was to find out about it organically. And it's not, some books about disability are a little bit in your face. This one is very gently representative and there's a deaf person in it. The author of course does have Ehlers-Danlos syndrome and so do four of her children.

 

BETH: Wow, that was going to be my question. I love that you found it in the wild, but I was going to say, you know, what's the author's background? I actually liked all the detail we went into there, Emma, because it's not my kind of thing. So now I know enough to have chats with you and other colleagues that are into this stuff without having to read it myself.

 

THEME TUNE

 

EMMA: Right on with the show then. I mean you can subscribe to us on BBC Sounds, please do. And if you're outside the UK, it's wherever you get your podcasts from. And please do get in touch. I love to hear from you, accessall@bbc.co.uk is the e-mail address.

Now my main interview on this episode of Access All is with an absolute superstar that I have been bumping into and chatting to in different ways for 20 years since she first came in to the podcast which used to be called Ouch, the BBC's disability podcast. And she was on work experience from Whiz Kids, which is a charity that provides wheelchairs for young people and is still going strong. Ruth Madeley has gone from strength to strength all the way up to film star status, which really became very evident when she came in to see us, didn't it, Beth?

 

BETH: It really did. I don't think we've ever had someone turn up before with an entourage of 10 people, no less.

 

EMMA: There were so many people and they were all different. There was like her access co-ordinator and I think there might have been a stylist in there and loads of PR, but it just made me so happy to think of a disabled person being at that level of looked after, you know?

 

BETH: Yeah, I mean, to add some context, we obviously had Richard Osman in a few months ago. He's a big star. He just came in by himself, got a taxi in. Sometimes you might have a politician in, say the Prime Minister or a high up minister, they might have like four or five people with them, but 10 was something else. And we were a bit worried, weren't we, Emma, because, they tend to sit in the background in what's known as the gallery, where it's often where I'm sat and I'll talk to Emma in her ear, but you need kind of it to be pretty quiet so that we can all concentrate. So I very strictly said, like, you can come in, but I want absolute silence, please. And I must have been in my teacher mode because I then said, I've got to go and get my laptop, bear with me. And when I came back in, they were all sat neatly in utter silence. And I said, you don't need to be quiet now, you can chat. And they're like, oh, no, we didn't we didn't want to upset you.

 

EMMA: With that size of entourage, you are a little bit worried that if you ask any question that's not on their list, that they will come and say, no, you can't do that. But they weren't like that at all.

 

BETH: And they let you have a good chat with Ruth because they were on a like a press day. So they'd already been to see Nick Grimshaw for 6 Music. And then they came down to us and then they were going off to do, I think, some newspaper interviews. And then they were flying to America for even more press. But they were really generous with their time, which was hugely appreciated. And Ruth seemed to really enjoy coming back to her roots, shall we say.

 

EMMA: It was a complete joy and an absolute pleasure. So take a listen.

 

MUSIC

 

EMMA: My guest this time is probably the most famous wheelchair user on screen right now. It's actress Ruth Madeley. You'll have seen her in Doctor Who, Years and Years, and most recently in The Rapture on BBC, where she was also an executive producer. Now Ruth is playing Judy Heumann in the film Being Heumann, which depicts the birth of the disability rights movement in the US, alongside Oscar-nominated actor Mark Ruffalo, if you don't mind. She's a very, very busy lady. I'm so glad she was able to come in for a chat. Ruth, hello, how are you?

 

RUTH: Oh, I'm so happy to be here. Thank you so much for having me.

 

EMMA: Being Heumann, what is it about?

 

RUTH: So this is about a specific moment in time in the '70s where people wanted to make it illegal to discriminate against disabled people and they wanted access for everybody. And the frustration that built up for years before this led to this epic punk rock sit-in in a federal building where 100 disabled people camped out and refused to leave this building until the 504 regulation was signed, which was the sentence in the bill to say that it was illegal to discriminate against disabled people. And they had the time of their lives in this building. It was like a rebellion, it was like punk rock. Sex, drugs, rock and roll.

 

EMMA: Yeah, there was a sex tent.

 

RUTH: There was a sex tent. But it was a really like unifying moment for them as disabled people. And it was such a big moment for Judy when she was basically learning how to be a leader and fight for a group rather than just herself.

 

[Clip]

They see you in front of the stairs and they think that you're the problem. The stairs are the problem! Joseph Califano, please. This is Judy Heumann. Judy Heumann. Judy Heumann. Who is this person?

[End of Clip]

 

EMMA: So it was in a government building in San Francisco and 504, which is mentioned quite a lot in the film, but it was so, so important, but it was basically no discrimination against disabled people in any situation that was given government money. So that could be healthcare, schools, that kind of thing.

 

RUTH: Yeah, transport, everything.

 

EMMA: Everything like that. And tell me a bit more about the woman you play, Judy Heumann.

 

RUTH: People who do know Judy Heumann know her as this fierce, formidable, ferocious woman who changed the world. Her impact was huge on all of us and the physical world around us as well in regards to access. But she was... just a woman from Brooklyn who didn't take no for an answer. She had polio when she was young. So she never remembered the time in her life when she wasn't disabled. And growing up, she wasn't allowed to go to school. She was denied access. I don't think she went to school until she was 10. And then she trained to be a teacher. And then she couldn't get a teaching license because she was considered a fire hazard. She had all of these moments in her life when she was constantly, I mean, how many times have I been called a fire hazard in my life? So many, have you?

 

EMMA: Yes, of course.

 

RUTH: Of course. Of course.

 

EMMA: Who will you have with you?

 

RUTH: I know who you have, what happens if the building's on fire? So she had constantly been met with barriers as had her mum and dad. So she was so focused on the end goal of making it illegal to discriminate against disabled people, that she was determined to do anything necessary to get that bill passed.

 

EMMA: And I sort of feel like you're the only one. You're the best place to play her. I mean, you played Barbara Lisicki in Then Barbara Met Alan, who was the mother of the disability rights movement in the UK.

 

RUTH: Yeah.

 

[Clip}

No more charity. What we want instead is real rights, real choices.

[End of clip]

 

EMMA: But also just your strength and your feistiness. How did you prepare? I mean, you had so much already, Ruth.

 

RUTH: Well, that means so much. Thank you so much, Emma. But I think, you know, what I found really hard was the fact that, I mean, I did, I knew of Judy and I knew about her position in our community as like the mother of the disability rights movement in the 70s, you know, and she was a formidable queen. And so I once, it was so easy to try and fall into like an impression or mimicking her. And I wanted to kind of strip all of that away and really find the humanity and maybe the things that people didn't know about her. So her uncertainty when she was in the building of whether this would work and how she could continue leading people. And I loved to find her moments of joy and her warmth and her vulnerability and her prickliness and her brashness sometimes, all of those things, she was so many things that it was really important to me to be able to show all of those because I can't stand it when a character is perfect or too likeable. I love a messy queen.

 

EMMA: And did you pull from your own life for that?

 

RUTH: Oh, I am a messy queen. And I get things wrong all the time and just like everybody else and I feel that to have space in a movie to be able to show that, especially when it comes to disability as a disabled woman, to be able to show that on screen, that was huge.

 

EMMA: There is a prickliness. You are in a position where you're the lead role in a massive film. There must have had to be prickliness in Ruth Madeley to get there.

 

RUTH: I mean, look.

 

EMMA: In a nice, nice prickle.

 

RUTH: I'm a very nice prickle. No, I'm a lot stronger now than I was when I first started in the industry. And I feel like I am much better now at advocating for not only myself, but what should go, you know once I'm not on set anymore. Like I never want to be the last disabled person that somebody hires. I want to be one of many. So I am very straight and direct on what I need. And and there's no wavering on that for me, which has changed now from the start. When I was so...

 

EMMA: What was it like at the start?

 

RUTH: It was so frightened to ask for anything because I didn't want to be seen as a problem and I didn't want them to think that I was going to cost them more money. All of that's really, really changed now and what a privileged position to be in to be able to... share that with other cast members on the set who hadn't done this before.

 

EMMA: Because there were a lot. There were a lot of disabled people in this movie. There are so many, maybe the most in any.

 

RUTH: I think we have to take that crown, surely.

 

EMMA: I mean, was that a logistical nightmare?

 

RUTH: Yeah, of course it was, course it was.

 

EMMA: Because if there were three of us in a bar or something, they get flustered.

 

RUTH: Oh my God, we've all been there. So yeah, I think I've nearly made people cry before asking for things. Anyway, it was hard work, but Apple was so dedicated to making sure that access was thought about and and done correctly from day one. It wasn't an afterthought. Everything was built with this in mind. But also we learnt as we went along, you know what it's like, nothing is right first time and nothing… it's an ever moving thing.

 

EMMA: Yeah, and if it's right for one person, which even makes it into the film, which I love, if it's right for one disabled person, it's not necessarily right for another disabled person.

 

RUTH: Exactly. But I mean, but that learning just, I felt, helped us all.

 

EMMA: Tell me some of the things that had to be thought about that maybe we wouldn't realise.

 

RUTH: The set, when we did a set walkthrough before we started filming and they showed me where all of the access was, the whole thing was ramps, there was no steps to get onto the stage or onto the set, which was amazing. But I remember the first time I went round it, I was like, we're going to have to do a sweep up, lads, because there's loads of nails on the floor.

 

EMMA: Nails on wheels.

 

RUTH: Nails on wheels, guys. And they went, oh my God, of course. But then also we were sat in period wheelchairs, which was just as uncomfortable as you can imagine.

 

EMMA: Tell me, yeah, tell me about wheelchairs in the '70s, because I actually was surprised to hear the whir of the powered wheelchair. I didn't even know there were powered wheelchairs in the '70s.

 

RUTH: They built them. It was incredible.

 

EMMA: So what was the difference between a '70s wheelchair and your current one?

 

RUTH: So I mean, this one is very lightweight and is designed very much for my body down to the last millimetre, whereas the '70s, like clinical wheelchair is not. They sourced these...

 

EMMA: …There's someone who's very interested in the history of wheelchairs…

 

RUTH: …But they found so many all over America! And they just had them shipped and then some of us had powered wheelchairs and some characters didn't. They had to build bigger batteries in them because the batteries would die so quickly on set. So there was so many different things to think about. And obviously if you're in a '70s wheelchair, you need to be able to transfer out of your chair and have regular breaks.

 

EMMA: So one of the other very unique things about this film is that the interaction, which is the case from the sit-in itself, you know, that happened in that San Francisco building in 1977. There's an awful lot of interaction between disabled people, a lot of disabled people helping each other…

 

RUTH: …yeah…

 

EMMA: …and supporting each other. How do you create that atmosphere and make it feel so realistic?

 

RUTH: You know something, I think the period before we started shooting, so we had a two-week rehearsal period, and that really, really helped. It helps us bond. It helped us learn about each other, each other's needs as well. And it was a place where we were allowed to be quite vulnerable in certain situations and share things when we felt we were ready to. And by the time we got to set, it was like life imitating art, art imitating life. It was literally just like we were in that building. I mean, movement on screen is something that I find fascinating anyway.

 

EMMA: Why?

 

RUTH: Especially when it comes to disability because I'm fascinated by the way a disabled person moves through the world. And I'm even more fascinated because we've been so starved of that for so many years to be able to see that on screen. And I was fascinated by how Judy is so free when she's in her chair and she's constantly moving. And then that's a stark contrast to when she is out of her chair and she is so reliant and vulnerable and has to wait for someone to come and help her pee. There's one scene where Rio, he's one of our actors, he plays Milton, and he is being transferred by the character of Dennis, played by Charlie, who's blind. And Charlie is being instructed by Daniel, who is a deaf person. It was just the most incredible thing to watch, and witness and that trust that we had to have in each other.

 

EMMA: Yeah.

 

RUTH: And also that Judy's disability was very different than mine. I'm ambulatory, so I can walk, but Judy couldn't. So it was interesting to play.

 

EMMA: So there must have been trust involved for you then.

 

RUTH: Yeah, it's huge trust. And also remembering, because I naturally…

 

EMMA: …remembering not to move...

 

RUTH: …I naturally sit and cross my legs for balance, just naturally for balance. And I remember Sian came up to me on one scene, she was like, you're moving your foot. I went, am I? I didn't even realise. So yeah, it was really interesting to be acting in a different body for three months.

 

EMMA: But you did have intimacy co-ordinators and access co-ordinators.

 

RUTH: We did.

 

EMMA: Tell people who don't know what they are and what they do and what they did in your film.

 

RUTH: A huge shout out to our access team. We had an access team, it was amazing. And over here we have access co-ordinators as well, who basically you tell them exactly what your needs are and they make sure that everything is put in place so that you can literally just turn up and do your job without having to educate, train, constantly be asking for the same thing. It takes such a weight off and they've become still quite a new thing…

 

EMMA: …yeah…

 

RUTH… access co-ordinators.

 

EMMA: But I mean, there must have had to be a fleet, and then, you know, there was a sex tent in the film. You have some…

 

RUTH: … spicy scenes!...

 

EMMA: …spicy scenes. I mean, whose idea was to bring the wheelchair back in?

 

RUTH: I love that moment because there's a shift in power all the time.

 

EMMA: I feel like we need to explain it a little bit.

 

RUTH: So we're basically, so Judy and a character Jim, they're having an intimate moment and in the excitement Jim kicks away Judy's chair. And for her, that's a panic for her. She wants it back because she doesn't like the idea of somebody like disregarding her chair and kicking it out of the way because she just can't get into it while she's so distracted about the fact that he's just kicked her chair away. So then she tells him to bring the chair back. He looks a bit crestfallen, bless him. And so she's like, right, now just do what I do. And now we're gonna have a great time. She's like, just, I'm gonna tell you what I want and you're gonna do it. So she just gets her way.

 

EMMA: Yeah. Do you know, can I just tell you that I interpreted that very differently?

 

RUTH: Did you interpret that we were gonna have sex in the chair?

 

EMMA: Well, that it might be used as some sort of prop.

 

RUTH: Well, you know what? Maybe it did. The camera's cut. So maybe, you know, it might have done. It probably did at some point.

 

EMMA: Mark Ruffalo's character, Mark Ruffalo, by the way, Mark Ruffalo's character had a line in the film which says welfare reform, what does that even mean? And it wasn't a thing to him. And we're still talking about it now from the film, what struggles they had still resonate with you as a disabled person today.

 

RUTH: I don't know a single disabled person who doesn't struggle in some way with access, especially public transport. That's one. With getting into employment, another. mental health support. There's so many different areas that it's the mental load of having to handle so many things every day relentlessly. And a lot of the stuff that these guys were fighting for, and I felt very much the same after I did Then Barbara Met Alan. A lot of the stuff that they were fighting for we're still arguing and fighting for today. And this feels increasingly more timely because of how much is under threat and being rolled back now.

 

EMMA: Because that line for someone in the UK watching that film, that line about welfare reform, it's about benefits.

 

RUTH: Benefits, yeah.

 

EMMA: And it's something they were thinking about then. Well, the money to stay alive and to have the lives they want is something people are thinking about now.

 

RUTH: Absolutely. It's like the disability tax. It's more expensive to be a disabled person. It's really, really hard.

 

EMMA: We should explain who Mark Ruffalo plays. He plays Joseph Califano. Who was he?

 

RUTH: He was a powerhouse in the government. But it's so funny 'cause when Mark first came to this, he was like, this guy is not a bad guy. He basically fought for desegregation, you know, he was big on helping people. But this particular thing Judy and disabled people wanted him to sign, would mean that the government would have to spend billions of dollars in like 60 days to change access to all public buildings, put kerb cuts everywhere. And he was like, I'm going to get fired if I do that. And Judy just saw him as the complete antagonist to all of it.

 

EMMA: Did you ever meet Judy?

 

RUTH: I met her on a Zoom once with a few other people. So yeah, and we became Instagram friends, but that was the fact that she knew my name…

 

EMMA: …yeah…

 

RUTH: …means so, so much to me. I don't think any time with Judy would have been enough for me. I think I would have…

 

EMMA: …yeah, just soak her up…

 

RUTH: … completely. I think I would have wanted to speak with her forever.

 

EMMA: And what do you think she'd think of this?

 

RUTH: I really think that she would be very, very proud of what we've done because Hollywood was her next goal. She was she went to the Oscars and she saw a bit the industry where she just was like, why is this so inaccessible? Why are there not more disabled people? And she was really cross about that. So I think with this film, if we were lucky enough to still have her with us, I think she would have definitely gone on to do more in the industry to make it more accessible for everybody.

 

EMMA: I mean, let's go on to some of the Hollywood aspects of this.

 

RUTH: Yeah.

 

EMMA: The red carpet, the stuff you've been to, the parties, the premiers, the outfits.

 

RUTH: I am very, very, very big on fashion. Fashion has always been a huge part of my life. I used to want to be a fashion designer.

 

EMMA: Did you?

 

RUTH: Yeah, I did, yeah, but I couldn't sew. I was terrible. My grandma was a dressmaker, so I've always loved fashion. And I was always very aware that I wanted to look very fashionable when people often thought that disabled people weren't. So to be in all of these outfits, it's like, I'm not gonna lie, 10-year-old Ruth is literally screaming with joy. Louis Vuitton have been so fantastic. They've dressed me for some stuff now on the press tour, and I went to their show, so that was really special. I've got a fantastic stylist who is wonderful at pulling looks and working on things together. And some things that we think wouldn't look right we try something different and then we tailor them to my body shape and my size. So there is so much that goes into it, but I just find that part of the fun.

 

EMMA: Yeah.

 

RUTH: So much fun.

 

EMMA: And it fascinates me, not long before this all blew up, you showed a picture. Again, I can't see it, so you might want to describe it, where you talk about your scoliosis scar and wanting to show that.

 

RUTH: Yeah.

 

EMMA: And that's all part of the fashion love, isn't it? And all part of the kind of representation.

 

RUTH: Absolutely. I mean, I would do anything and everything to cover my scar when I was going on nights out with the girls when I was growing up, you know. And now it's something that I'm really proud of. And if a dress is low at the back, all more power to that, I love it.

 

EMMA: It's part of who you are.

 

RUTH: Oh yeah, it's a work of art, my back, it's an absolute car wreck, but I'm so, yeah, it's definitely my badge of honour.

 

EMMA: Ruth, last time we spoke, you had just got engaged to Joe.

 

RUTH: Yes.

 

EMMA: How is married life treating you?

 

RUTH: I'm so happy, yeah. I mean, look, whether we got married or not, we were going to be this, he's my person and I'm his, so yeah but married life is just a dream. I absolutely love it.

 

EMMA: What does he think about all this?

 

RUTH: We both think it's absolutely hysterical because we've known each other since we were kids. So the fact that he was like, oh my God, the fact that people are trusting you with this level of responsibility is hysterical to me. And I love the fact that he's not in the industry. So it's really nice to be able to go home and just be normal, and you know wear his clothes for a bit and just slob in bed.

 

EMMA: Yeah, Ruth's life outside of the cameras.

 

RUTH: I know it's definitely when I went about the Louis Vuitton thing. I was literally when I found out, I think I had croissant round my mouth. I had coffee in my hand. I was wearing his shirt. I had my hair piled up. I was like, oh my God, they're flying me to Paris for Louis Vuitton. Joe just looked at me and was like, why, why? I was like, exactly, I don't know, but we're going. So much fun.

 

EMMA: Any glimpses into what's next? I know you've got this for a while. It's out on Apple TV in November the 13th.

 

RUTH: Yep.

 

EMMA: After that?

 

RUTH: I'm also writing. I'm working with a lot of gorgeous production companies who are really passionate about, you know, my writing. And so I think that's my next… my next goal is to get my stuff commissioned.

 

EMMA: Because that is what you started off with.

 

RUTH: It is. I mean, I better put the degree to some use at some point, you know. But no, it's really fun to be able to do both.

 

EMMA: Thank you so much for joining me on Access All, Ruth. This has been an absolute dream and a pleasure.

 

RUTH: Oh, mine too. Thank you so much for having me.

 

MUSIC

 

EMMA: Thanks again to Ruth Madeley. I had a lovely time, Beth, chatting to her about all her rise and rise.

 

BETH: But actually, Emma, it's not the first time Ruth has played someone so important to disability rights. So a few years ago, she played the UK's mother to the disability rights movement, Barbara Lisicki, in the film Then Barbara Met Alan. Barbara is one of many disability activists who's also featured in a new BBC Radio 4 series which is about to come out called For Pity's Sake.

 

EMMA: The slogan of those activists was Piss on pity. The name didn't get through for some reason so it's called For Pity's Sake. It's in eight parts, starting life on Radio 4 and it kind of charts the story of how disability legislation came to be in the UK starting with Barbara and Alan and their kind of move onto the arts scene with quite political comedy, disability comedy and kind of more disability artists joining them and then them maybe thinking that they could do some activism for disability rights. And these activists went on to chain themselves to buses and trains in a fight for accessible transport. And they also shut down the 1992 ITV telethon, which was a kind of a 27, 28-hour-long money-raising TV, live TV extravaganza, which kind of relied on films which showed the very medical side of disability, and which they say showed disability as pitied let's say and these people weren't having it so they made it into the studio and shut down the telethon and there's a great story in there about activist Sue Elsegood who ran over Chris Tarrant's foot in her wheelchair apparently.

 

BETH: Wow I did not know that. The series is presented by Sophie Morgan who you'll probably recognize from things like the Paralympics and here is a flavour of what to expect.

 

[Clip]

MULTIPLE VOICES:

We were taking our own fate into our own hands.

…to the bus…I've just chained myself to it.

They stormed the barricades.

What do we want? Civil Rights! When do we want them? Now!

It was quite empowering to be disobedient.

You're having to de-arrest me because your vehicles are inaccessible.

They didn't hold back. It was truly terrifying.

Pressure is mounting for the Minister for Disabled People Nicholas Scott to resign after he admitted misleading the Commons.

We're extremely angry. We are not weak and we will never be seen as weak again.

A group of disabled people left their wheelchairs and tried to crawl into the House of Commons today.

Our problems are not our bodies, they're society. That's our problems.

Disability Discrimination Bill, second reading.

Things are going to change and we're going to change them.

[End of clip]

 

EMMA: The story's not just about the activists on the streets. It's also about the brains behind the very first disability legislation in the UK, the Disability Discrimination Act, which came to be in 1995. That's now part of the Equality Act that we know today. The full box set is available on BBC Sounds from the 16th of November.

 

MUSIC

 

EMMA: Okay Beth, how do I move from that to my story about buying knives on the internet?

 

BETH: Wow, I really hope you were talking about kitchen knives there Emma.

 

EMMA: I am actually talking about kitchen knives. We've had the same knives for years and years and years and honestly they're just ridiculous. They don't work at all. So I went ahead and tried to buy some in a really popular retailer on their website. But I had to prove, understandably, that I was over 18. But it was a verification system that relied on taking a picture of my face. And independently, I just could not get it to frame me properly.

 

BETH: So you're kind of taking a selfie, but within their little window, camera window.

 

EMMA: Well, I believe that's what was happening. It kept telling me to move the phone to the right slightly, up slightly, down slightly, to the left slightly, move back from it a little bit. I just couldn't do it because I can't see anything and I can't see their parameters and you know I'm terrible at taking photos of myself at the best of times. So I did have to get my husband to sort of do what he does when I'm doing like passport photos to just kind of duck down behind me when it was time to take the photo. I feel like I'm not the only person having this problem.

 

BETH: No, you're absolutely not. We're having massive conversations at the moment around AI and the pros and cons, but one of the conversations that BBC Wales has been having recently is around facial differences and how some AI systems are trying to touch up and quote marks, improve what people look like or make them more homogenous so everyone looks the same. It came to light because someone called Rhiannon had experienced this. She was in a working situation, so we've got a clip of Rhiannon explaining that.

 

[Clip]

You know the software Canva.

Yeah.

It's used by so many people and in the newsletter was my image and I was just speaking so my hands were up because I talk a lot with my hands, I'll be honest, I need to stop, I need to put my hands down. What happened was that it was auto retouched and luckily I was able to see it before it went out to anybody. I was like, who is that person? I don't recognise that person. So I'm quite pink usually and all of that had gone. I've got like hard skin on my hands and that had also been smoothed over.

[End of clip]

 

BETH: So as Rhiannon mentioned, her workplace used Canva to create this image and they did get in touch with Canva who said they take this matter very seriously and its system does not automatically retouch photos. But the BBC Wales investigation went a lot wider. They tested five popular AI tools and they found that Gemini 3.6 Thinking, Grok Fast and ChatGPT 6 changed the facial differences but didn't change anything else, like they didn't touch up the background or they didn't change any of the clothing. Whereas Anthropic's Claude Opus 5.5 and Meta's AI thinking refused to change anything to the image saying the individual had not consented to that. So it's kind of really interesting that actually these guardrails are being put in and it's sort of understanding that you shouldn't be changing how someone looks unless they've requested it. Changing Faces, which is a charity which supports people with facial difference. They estimate there's about five million people in the UK who have a facial difference. So we're talking, you know, lots and lots of people and we need to see a variety of people and this infringement shouldn't be happening. So it was a really interesting investigation by BBC Wales. So check it out if you want to find out more.

 

EMMA: Big up Gemma Dunstan, the journalist who did all that.

We have some feedback.

 

BETH: We do. It's always so nice to hear from you. So we had a lovely e-mail from 17-year-old Navya who listened to our Richard Osman episode from a few months ago. And she said she was really inspired when he was talking about AI again. And what Richard said was, I think Emma, you asked him about the jobs market and how AI is kind of... taking on a lot of the work that a lot of people would do and he was saying but hey disabled people are so good with solutions and workarounds and just often think more creatively that he's pretty sure disabled people can outlast AI. So that got Navya thinking. She said my mother is hard of hearing. And so I created Raaha, which is a free AI platform for neurodivergent people to decide whether a job might fit for them and how they work personally. So that sounds really interesting. So love to know more about that.

And also we heard from Neil who said, I was delighted to hear on the last episode that you have discovered Parkrun. I hope you get as much from it as I do as a totally blind person. And Neil says, I find the experience of volunteering just as rewarding as running and have done so on 57 occasions. And he says, while not every role is accessible to do by himself. It just takes a slight adjustment. He goes on to add, Emma, on the 7th of November, I will be running my 250th park run in Inverurie.

 

EMMA: Inverurie.

 

BETH: Inverurie, 20 miles north of Aberdeen. Perhaps you could join us?

 

EMMA: Neil, not the 7th of November, but someday we will do one together. How about that? And I will particularly run with you because you sent me an e-mail and I love to hear from people. I really want you to send me emails, tell me what you're doing. You can ask me to do stuff if you want, and if I can, I will. Oh my goodness, did I just say that? Email accessall@bbc.co.uk. That's it for this month. Thank you so much for listening. If you want to hear hundreds of more episodes of Access All, you can subscribe to us on BBC Sounds or if you're outside the UK, it's wherever you get your podcasts from. See you soon. Bye.

Podcast

Podcast

Get the latest episodes of the Access All podcast the moment a new episode goes live!

Podcast