Guidance: Anonymity
Key Points
There are occasions where the reporting of a story or securing a contribution depends upon using a source or contributor who wishes to remain anonymous. But the decision to obscure identity requires an editorial, legal, welfare or other justification.
- The content maker must consider why the person wishes to remain anonymous.
- When anonymity is offered, it is important to make sure that the BBC is in a position to honour any commitment that is given. Methods of anonymity that are used should be sufficient to meet the anonymity required.
- The most important question to pose to someone requesting anonymity is “Whom do you want to be anonymous from - from the general public or from people who know you well?”
- When disguising identities effectively, be aware that some technical solutions can be reversed, and distinctive features, such as hair, gait and voice, may need to be taken into account.
- Care should be taken not to reveal several pieces of information that could compromise a person’s anonymity when put together: so-called “jigsaw identification”.
Introduction
Obscuring identity is not ideal for content makers or for our audiences. Sources and contributors should speak on the record whenever practicable and their identities and credentials made known to the audience so that they can judge the source’s credibility, reliability and whether or not they are in a position to have sufficient knowledge of the subject or events. It should also be remembered that the methods by which identities are disguised can sometimes compromise the content that is published visually and/or aurally.
It would be impossible to make some programmes unless identities can be obscured effectively. This could be because of legal, editorial, duty of care and/or regulatory considerations. The content maker must consider why the person wishes to remain anonymous. Do they have something to hide beyond their identity? Is it in order to protect someone else, for example children or other family members who might be at risk should their identity be known?
When it is not self-evident to the audience, the reasons why the production granted anonymity to a source should be explained. The strongest rationale for granting anonymity is simply to protect the contributor from illegitimate retaliation, harassment or undesirable consequences for providing information.
Best Practice
- When anonymity is offered, it is important to make sure that the BBC is in a position to honour any commitment that is given. Methods of anonymity that are used should be sufficient to meet the anonymity required.
Careful consideration should be given before offering a guarantee of anonymity because disguising someone’s identity completely is difficult to achieve. Such a guarantee should only be considered in extremely rare circumstances. Specialist advice, including legal and editorial policy, should be sought.
The most important question to pose to someone requesting anonymity is “Whom do you want to be anonymous from - from the general public or from people who know you well?”
Accurate and contemporaneous notes of conversations with sources and contributors about anonymity should be kept. A recording is preferable if possible. Having agreed the level and type of anonymity with the contributor it’s good practice to write down what’s agreed and get the contributor to sign the agreement so there isn’t any room for confusion.
When offering anonymity content makers must take into account the implications of any possible court order demanding the disclosure of un-transmitted or un-published material. Be aware that materials that name them might have to be disclosed and could reveal their identity. (This includes notebooks, administrative paperwork, phone records, computer files, exchanges on social media apps, emails as well as video and audio rushes.) Before taking any action, a court order should be referred to Litigation to discuss which materials might compromise the anonymity of a contributor or source.
Identities may also need to be obscured when the content maker is unable to gain consent to show someone identifiably, for example when secretly filming for consumer or social research to expose anti-social or criminal practice but the individuals involved are simply illustrative of the behaviour, or not sufficiently culpable or responsible for their actions. In these instances when the person filmed either refuses to give consent or when the content maker is unable to contact them to secure consent, then the effort to disguise their identity should be proportionate to the private information that might inadvertently be revealed.
The Editorial Guidelines outline other circumstances when it is acceptable to disguise identities in Section 8 Reporting Crime and Anti-Social Behaviour 8.4.29 – 8.4.30.
Legal rights to anonymity
Victims and alleged victims of sexual offences, some human trafficking offences and female genital mutilation have a legal right to anonymity. The rules regarding anonymity in these cases are complex and the right of anonymity cannot always be waived.
Teachers also have a legal right of anonymity in some circumstances when an allegation of an offence is made concerning a pupil.
Making Anonymity Effective
Footage and photos of people who wish to remain anonymous are often published provided the person’s face and hair are thoroughly disguised or obscured. The latest advances in technology mean there is a risk of traditional blurring techniques being reversed although it is rare that someone will employ technical means to try to discover the identity of sources or contributors in our recordings or images. This is more likely where content features witnesses to a serious crime, whistleblowers or people deemed enemies of a foreign state, but as the technology becomes more widespread and sophisticated, the risk of more people attempting to deanonymise material to identify contributors increases.
This means that the utmost care must be taken when considering how to anonymise contributors effectively, especially, where the impact on a contributor of being identified in this way would cause significant risk of harm to that person or breach the standards of the BBC.
Examples of high-risk scenarios may include:
- Where there is a legal right to anonymity
- Where identification could put a person at substantial physical or psychological risk.
- Children where there is a protection order in place.
- Law enforcement officers who are themselves involved in covert operations
- Whistleblowers to whom the BBC owes duties of confidentiality
Risk will also often be higher where the context suggests a particular group or setting linked to the contributor, for example a particular school or hospital.
Filming Techniques
Filming techniques can be highly effective in ensuring anonymisation which is resistant to reversal techniques, as long as they are done sufficiently to ensure the level of anonymity required.
An interview can be staged without including the face or other defining characteristics. Observational filming can use close ups and cutaways rather than revealing individual faces.
Modern cameras, that can capture high-definition images with lots of data in the blacks, could potentially leave a silhouetted contributor vulnerable to de-anonymisation.
Be aware that what may appear as insignificant detail (e.g. a piece of jewellery or the way a person walks) may reveal identity to those familiar with the person.
A tattoo, an unusual watch, a distinctive item of clothing, the particular way in which someone gestures, or even the location in which filming takes place, can all reveal identity. Be cautious of using footage of someone walking filmed from behind as a person’s gait can be particularly distinctive. Sometimes it may be appropriate to ask a contributor to provide a disguise for themselves for an interview. With victims and whistleblowers different clothes and/or a wig could be supplied by the production to be worn in the interview and then disposed of. (If filmed from behind a wig can help with anonymity.) Be aware that any such props could affect how an interview is received by the audience. It may be appropriate to take the contributor to a different, neutral, location for the interview. If possible, try to show the contributor how they will appear on camera by letting them check a sample shot to ensure they are happy with the level of disguise that has been achieved for them.
In some cases, the risks are such that restaging the interview with an actor is the most effective option. This guarantees the individual’s identity cannot be reversed by technology. Audiences should be informed if an actor is used, and the loss of emotional impact should be weighed against the level of anonymity required.
Solutions at Editing Stage
To achieve anonymity, at the edit stage, robust editing methods should be used which cannot be de-anonymised. These should remove the underlying visual signals (such as the face).
Methods include the use of a solid colour shape laid over the visual signal. The solid colour shape can also then be pixelated to soften the visual impact. (Pixelation is not safe on its own as a method of anonymisation.)
Another method is to create an AI synthetically generated face which replaces the real face. The synthetic face is then blurred. Advice should be sought from Editorial Policy.
It should be noted that some techniques may take more time and involve more cost to a production.
Where anonymity is required, still images, including text, and car number plates and house numbers should also be anonymised by removing the underlying visual signals, for example with a solid colour shape. For text a solid black or white shape may be more appropriate, depending on the background colour.
Where the BBC is publishing content that has been blurred or otherwise obscured by a third party, such as material from the police and other public authorities, a judgement should be made about whether additional editing is required in order to meet the BBC's own editorial standards.
More details of editing options are here: https://editingsupport.co.uk/anonymity
Basic blurring, such as Gaussian blurring, may also still be appropriate to obscure identifying information in situations where there is not an editorial or legal requirement to ensure anonymity. Advice is available from Editorial Policy and Programme Legal Advice.
Voice
When disguising a voice, recording a “voice over” by another person is an effective guarantee of anonymity. As the safety of voice masking tools is unclear, it is advised against using them when anonymity is required. In selecting the “voice over” artist (e.g. for age, gender, accent) bear in mind the impact this choice might have on the credibility of the interview and whether it risks materially misleading audiences. Where anonymity is essential, any technical solution that uses any element of or technique based on the original voice must not be used as this could be reversed – in these circumstances, do not transform the original voice (whether by older methods like pitch shifting, or by using AI).
Audiences should be told if the voice is not that of the contributor. Whilst content makers sometimes find that replacing a voice in this way can reduce the emotional impact, this loss should be weighed against the level of anonymity promised. Remember that whilst the story being produced may be intended for transmission or publication on a particular BBC outlet or outlets, the story may well be transmitted or reproduced globally on other outlets without the content maker’s knowledge or consent. The safety of contributors or sources whose identity may be inadvertently revealed internationally, in all media, in perpetuity should be considered.
Jigsaw Identification
Care should be taken not to reveal several pieces of information in words or images that could compromise a person’s anonymity when put together: so-called “jigsaw identification”.
This may require care in the way a contributor is described, obscuring house numbers, editing out certain pieces of information (whether spoken by the contributor or others), and taking care not to reveal the precise location of a contributor’s home.
Avoiding the jigsaw effect may also necessitate scrutiny of other non-BBC media to ensure that when the BBC publishes certain facts, and other details are released on other platforms these reports, taken together, do not reveal identity.
Even if details have already been placed in the public domain on other radio, TV and digital and social media outlets, editors need to check that if used together in an item, they do not compromise a person’s anonymity. The item may need to contain fewer details or no new information of its own to avoid this.
Particular care should be taken across the BBC’s news outlets. For instance, a web editor for bbc.co.uk might use someone’s age and the town that they live near. But the news editor of the 6 o’clock bulletin on BBC One might opt to leave out their age, but name the small village they live in unless there was close liaison between the two editors. Putting the two stories together could complete the jigsaw.
Guarantees to Contributors relating to Anonymity
When a content maker agrees to obscure an identity or personal information it is important that the contributor is given sufficient information to be able to understand in advance what measures are proposed, including the degree of protection that will result.
It should not be assumed that a contributor will necessarily appreciate the fine distinction between obscuring their identity in BBC content and making sure they are not identifiable. The sensitivity of the particular circumstances should be judged when considering what level of protection is appropriate to protect a contributor’s identity.
To reduce the possibility of any subsequent misunderstanding, content makers should ensure that contributors understand exactly how their voice and/or image will be disguised (eg by using an actor’s voice and by using a colour shape with pixelation on top to disguise their identity.) For further details on anonymity in The Editorial Guidelines see Section 6 Fairness 6.4.31-36.
Archives
If any archive content is re-edited in order to remove blurring, this form should be completed: