Today, Radio 4, 20 September 2025

Complaint

The programme included a discussion on Gaza and the prospects for Palestinian statehood.  A listener complained that it failed to cite the 7 October attacks and the impression was therefore given that Israel’s military assault and the humanitarian crisis were unrelated to those events, fostering a narrative that attacks on Israel were acts of legitimate resistance to colonial conquest. The ECU considered the complaint in the light of the BBC’s editorial standards of impartiality.


Outcome

The 7 October attacks were not the topic of the discussion.  The ECU noted, however, that one of the participants spoke of the significance of “2023, and the last couple of years”, which listeners would have taken as a reference to those attacks and their aftermath.  The ECU could therefore see no grounds for believing the item would have given the impression complained of.

Not upheld